Archive

George Patton’s Summer of 1944

George Patton’s Summer of 1944

Nearly 70 years ago, the lieutenant general began his advance toward the German border.

by Victor Davis Hanson // National Review Online

 

Share This
VDH’s Blade of Perseus

About VDH’s Blade of Perseus

View Full Bio →

Discussion (16)

Join the conversation. Logged in subscribers avoid the Captcha verification and get priority commenting approvals. No vulgarity, links, or code allowed.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

MTT 3 years ago

Did you need to use such demeaning language? Try being kind, correcting gently rather than with coarse words.

Mary 3 years ago

Fred, Trier has also been Roman, Belgic Gaulish, Frankish, Eastern Franconian/Holy Roman Empire, French, and Prussian.

Gerald King 7 years ago

As the pincer started closing in on the Germans, Patton's Third Army had already taken Argentan and was starting to head north to Falaise relatively unopposed to close the gap when Bradley told Patton to halt his army on Montgomery's orders. Bradley instead ordered the Third Army's XV Corps to "concentrate on operations in another direction." The XV Corps troops in Argentan were ordered to withdraw, which in effect ended the Corps participation in the pincer movement. Patton vehemently objected but obeyed the order, which left an exit for the German forces in the Falaise Pocket. Montgomery's British and Canadian armies were finally able to close the gap but not before 50,000 to 100,000 (the actual number has been disputed by historians) Nazi troops were able to escape. Many of these fleeing Nazis were killed on the road by Allied fighters along with the destruction of their tanks and artillery, but the ones who escaped were reorganized and rearmed and came back to haunt the cavalrymen of 106th Cavalry Group in the future battles to come. (Much has been said about why Patton was ordered to halt, but the most accepted reason by many historians was to give Montgomery the glory in reaching Falaise first. This can be traced all the way back to Sicily where Patton beat Montgomery to Messina.) Bradley should have told Montgomery to take a hike. Patton would have been much more explicit.

home 10 years ago

cmkgszqmdvnodgwvximniqva

Fred 12 years ago

Dear Ed, you moron, Trier is a German city, not French.

John Nicholas 12 years ago

I agree that Patton was a better tactician and his style and knowledge reflect that. Bradley was not the tactician, his gifts were definitely more strategic. Great stories like 'Should I give it back?' The real issue is understanding the master plan and your part in it. Patton in many ways was like Montgomery. Wanting to be out in front and leading. The strategic concept of the Western Allies was from day one, advance on a broad united front. If the concept had been a hard driving spear, then several options existed. Montgomery, Simpson, Patton and Devers all vie for being chosen. The issue was to win the war, not the battle. There were a lot of things going on. Air raids, resistance groups, National Pride, adequate supply, governing those areas captured from the enemy. Look at what happened on the Eastern Front with just resistance groups, supply and governing areas captured from the enemy. Major issues there that were not nearly the problem in Northern Europe during 1944. Most of that was the strategic concept of a broad front advancing as a united army. The last sentence is the summation of Mr. Hansen's piece and is very fitting for the 3rd Army. It is great to see the individual pride of the soldiers passed down for the current group to take pride in. Part of that pride should be individual effort; part of it should be the National Result.

Mark Borzillo 12 years ago

While I have read almost everything written about Patton and think is brand of leadership is sorely missing today, I cannot forget he was part of the reprehensible attack on other armed services vets during the 30's when they were protesting for their promised benefits. I guess Hoover and MacArthur have to take blame for that, too. That was a sad day in US history.

dan 12 years ago

shame on bradley for making such a statement. what motivates any man to be a 3 or a 4 or 5 star general? it aint the pay and the housing! the boys at west point are trained to fight and study daily for 4 years for the common good, but also, for their own glory. bradley once knew that. he forgot. patton didnt. sour grapes. thats why george c. scott, and not karl malden was cast as patton.

dan 12 years ago

once again in war, crucial decisions of our government and military were affected by the opinions of narrow minded american civilians who couldn't understand world politics/war/military strategy/military leadership if their they had to. ignorant arm-chair quarterbacks. and now its worse than in ww2 and vietnam. even our president and his cabinet fit this description. when will we ever learn? maybe once we are slaves to the chinese or muslims.

CPT John R. Sweet 12 years ago

I enjoyed this article as a reminder of the events of this month 7 decades ago. I was also introduced to the Patton legend as a child watching George C. Scott's portrayal-- I have spent years trying to wade through the lore to understand the historical facts. I agree with Dr. Hanson's assessment that Patton was more gifted than Bradley. Bradley went on to become a 5-star General of the Army, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs, etc. He had over 40 years to secure his own historical reputation, and secure it he did (even acting as a consultant in the classic movie "Patton.") Rarely mentioned is the giant intelligence failure prior to the Ardennes offensive, or his plodding pace through the hedgerows of Normandy the previous summer. Bradley was ambitious and a schemer-- far from the humble GI Joe he wanted to portray. Certainly the observation of E. Dwight Salmon's discussed above was true-- Patton's style and his habit of exceeding the standard won him few friends among his officer peers. I recommend LTC Carlo d'Este's PATTON: A GENIUS FOR WAR.

merle clark 12 years ago

Mr. Hanson: Been reading your articles for years, have some of your books. Yesterday's article about the summer of 1944 and General Patton particularly was meaningful for me. My father, one of those conscripted GI's, was a truck driver in the 80th Division of the Third Army. In many discussions with him he told me precisely the substance of your article yesterday. He said they were moving so fast getting fuel and ammunition to the tanks and troops that the supply dwindled or ran out. Then the rains, the mud, then the fighting around the Moselle River and areas where the German army dug in, then the Bulge (driving all night to get there in blinding snow), on into Germany and into Austria as the war ended. In 1994 I, my father, and my 10 year old son joined the 80th division for a fiftieth anniversary reunion tour of the 80th's route in 1944.

JW Carter 12 years ago

My great uncle Alvin Cowin of Caruthers/Kingsburg served in 3rd Army and was at the Bulge and pulled and manned an artillery gun. Alvin like most of his men cussed George up and down. Before he passed away I met and wrote about in voices of valor Sam Kalfman who was one of Patton's Buck privates showed me his poetry. Patton was dyslectic and a horrible poet according to him. When Sam forgot to wear a helmet while typing he told me Patton knocked it off his head and he was demoted...When I think of Patton I think of George C Scott. I enjoyed your insight and article. Jack Pearls Vlood and Guts Patton is a favorite....

Henry 12 years ago

I have always believed much the same thing that Victor Davis Hanson writes of George Patton. That is until the last few years when I read more about the European theater in WWII and more specificaly about Omar Bradley. As most historians he follows the popular version of Patton and Bradley but the real evidence, the real flow of events is not always the popular version. One would do well to read Jim DeFelices' "Omar Bradley" an impeccably researched book on our nations last five star general. While I still admire greatly George Patton and his abilities Omar Bradley was the true unsung hero and Patton's enabler!

David Seward 12 years ago

I had the pleasure of knowing E. Dwight Salmon who sat on General Eisenhower's staff. Salmon was chief historian for the Euopean Theater. He retired in 1962 after a distinguished career as history professor at Amherst College. I asked him if he had met General Patton during the war and he replied, " Yes, once.....and that was enough!" He went on to tell me that Patton was indeed a student of military history which augmented is genius as a tactician on the battle field. However, his flamboyant and sometimes caustic personality did not serve him well as an officer among officers.. Professor Salmon passed away in 1993 at the age of 98.

Stephen Downing 12 years ago

I had the opportunity to spend several days with Omar Bradley about three months prior to his death. I asked him, "What about Patton?" Bradley chuckled and replied,"Ol' George. The biggest problem I had with him was his battle plans. He was only interested in glory. Didn't give a damn about the casualty rate " The entire visit was fascinating. Steve Downing Long Beach

Ed Powell 12 years ago

Approaching the French city of Trier, Patton was ordered not to try to enter the city. Patton ignored the order and took Trier. When rumor of this filtered back to rear echelons, another frantic message came from Army Group Headquarters that under no circumstances should Patton attempt to capture Trier. Patton sent a brief response: "Have captured Trier. Do you want me to give it back?" If only we had generals like this again.