We are very far from a politics of ideological purity and high character.
Many have weighed in on whether Donald Trump’s agendas — to the extent that they are different from what are now ratified Republican policies — are crackpot, unworkable, or radical: e.g., building a wall to enhance border enforcement (“And make Mexico pay for it!”), renegotiating trade deals with China, promoting Jacksonian nationalism rather than ecumenical internationalism, suspending immigration from Middle East war zones (after Trump dropped his call for complete Muslim exclusion), and disparaging an Eastern-corridor elite that derives privilege from the intersection of big politics, money, and the media.
No doubt, some of Trump’s flamboyant invective is isolationist, nativist, and protectionist. Certainly, we are in the strangest campaign of the last half-century, in which members of Trump’s own party are among his fiercest critics. In contrast, the ABC/NBC/CBS Sunday-morning liberal pundits feel no need to adopt NeverHillary advocacy. They apparently share little “Not in my name” compunction over “owning” her two decades of serial lying, her violations of basic ethical and legal protocols as secretary of state, her investment in what can be fairly termed a vast Clinton pay-to-play influence-peddling syndicate, and the general corruption of the Democratic primary process.
Amid the anguish over the Trump candidacy, we often forget that the present age of Obama is already more radical than most of what even Trump has blustered about. We live in a country for all practical purposes without an enforceable southern border. Over 300 local and state jurisdictions have declared themselves immune from federal immigration laws — all without much consequence and without worry that a similar principle of nullification was the basis of the American Civil War or that other, more conservative cities could in theory follow their lead and declare themselves exempt from EPA jurisdiction or federal gun-registration laws. Confederate nullification is accepted as the new normal, and, strangely, its antithesis of border enforcement and adherence to settled law is deemed xenophobic, nativist, and racist.
The president of the United States, on matters from immigration to his own health-care act, often has declined to enforce federal laws — sometimes because it was felt that to do so would have been injurious to his 2012 reelection bid. The reputations of agencies such as the IRS and the VA no longer really exist; we concede that they are politicized, corrupt, or hopelessly inept. An attorney general being found in contempt of Congress raises no more of an eyebrow than that same chief law-enforcement officer referring to African Americans as “my people” or writing off Americans in general as a “nation of cowards.”
On cultural matters, I too was disappointed at the plagiarism of lines in Melania Trump’s convention speech and thought her speechwriter should at least have been summarily fired. But I am afraid that ethical high horse also long ago left the barn. The new normal regarding intellectual theft was apparently established by the likes of Stephen Ambrose, Joe Biden, Fareed Zakaria, Doris Kearns Goodwin, and Maureen Dowd, all of whom suffered few, if any, lasting professional consequences for their outright larcenies of others’ work.
Quite a while ago, too, we entered the age of postmodern fabulism, in which representatives of the president of the United States casually admitted, in response to criticism, that large segments of Obama’s best-selling autobiography were simply “composites,” a sort of euphemism for making stuff up. From Brian Williams’s pseudo-combat reporting to Hillary Clinton’s dodging bullets in the Balkans, we are now what we say we are — without much consequence any more for flat-out lying. Does any public commentator worry much that Senator Elizabeth Warren’s entire trajectory to Harvard was predicated on her abject and comical lie that she was a rare and sought-after Native American law professor?
I am worried about Trump’s flamboyance and about his sloppy and dangerous references to NATO and U.S. foreign commitments. But from the reaction to his ad hoc and sometimes incoherent musings, one would think that the next president was inheriting a time of peace and stability — not one in which the entire Middle East has imploded, reset with Putin has become a nightmare of Russian expansionism not seen since the Soviet period, “jayvee” and “on-the-run” terrorists are insidiously destroying the calm of the entire international order, and China is creating artificial islands with commensurate “sovereign” air and sea space. If there is one region in the world that is safer and more stable than it was in 2008, would someone please identify it? Iraq? Syria? Ukraine? Libya? North Korea? France? Baton Rouge? For now I am worried about what was and is rather than what might be. Are there any traditional U.S. allies that feel more secure in their partnership with us? Israel? Japan? France?
It is a fair wager that a supposedly isolationist President Trump would be more likely to attend an anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall or the liberation of Auschwitz than would a supposedly internationalist President Obama — or for that matter a European unity rally after horrific terrorist bombings. If Trump were to find time for GloZell for an interview, no doubt we would hear that it was confirmation of his shallowness.
We have already seen the shoot-from-the-hip Trump back down on his idiotic idea of denying all Muslims entry into the U.S. (as opposed to those seeking to emigrate from war zones and terrorist-rife nations of the Middle East). So far, we’ve seen no impulse on the part of Barack Obama or Hillary Clinton to simply employ the terms jihadist, radical Islamist, or Islamic terrorist the next time dozens of Americans are blown up or mowed down by someone shouting Allahu akbar!
Is Trump’s threatened “isolationism” worse than the present “lead from behind” or the empty step-over lines, deadlines, and red lines of the last seven years? Or than refusing to increase security at Benghazi and creating fables to hide the dereliction? I often hear the question: “Who knows what Trump might do?” I hear it much more often, in fact, than I hear anyone recall “We came, we saw, he [Qaddafi] died” or “What difference does it make?” The point is not to excuse Trump with “you too” moral equivalence, or to cynically race to the bottom of low-bar politics, but again to remind our ethicists that we live in an age characterized by Petronius’s Satyricon, not the elder Cato’s moral republic — and if they object to that fact, there were plenty of occasions to voice their outrage long before Donald J. Trump left The Apprentice. Trump may well be Trimalchio, but neither Clinton nor Obama is a Scipio (more likely a Catiline, Clodius, or Milo).
I would prefer Trump to be more socially conservative, but compared with what? We have gone from Democratic opposition to gay marriage in 2008 to a new normal in 2016 of slandering those who oppose the idea of transgender restrooms in primary schools. There is a degree of racial polarization not seen since the 1960s, one in which activists invited to the Oval Office include people, like Al Sharpton and Black Lives Matter leaders, who either have advocated the shooting of police officers or have been affiliated with marches that have chanted such threats.
I agree that Trump is capable of reckless talk and symbolism, but heedlessness is also the new normal when the president of the United States praises the album To Pimp a Butterfly, whose cover features the corpse of an eye-less white judge, his apparently violent demise celebrated by hipsters on the White House lawn.
When the IRS is sicced on political opponents, AP journalists’ communications are tapped by the administration, and an obscure videomaker is jailed on trumped-up parole violations to cement a lying narrative about Benghazi, and all this is greeted by relative somnolence, then the currency of outrage has been drastically cheapened.
The difference between a reckless Trump, Clinton, and Obama is not necessarily one of temperament, sobriety, or judgment, but often one of delivery and assumed establishmentarianism: For some reason Ivy League accents, government résumés, and liberal fides are supposed to repackage outrageousness as a mere slip, an aberration, rather than a window into a dark soul. A much-reviled Trump eliminated his primary opponents through invective and character assassination in open debate; a much-praised sober and judicious Clinton eliminated Bernie Sanders, in part, according to WikiLeaks, through her control of a biased and corrupt Democratic National Committee.
Put “corpse-man” or a cruel joke about the Special Olympics into the mouth of Trump, and we easily would find additional proof of his ignorance and callousness; from the silver tongue of Obama they are either minor gaffes or perhaps proof of the stress he endures on our behalf. There really is a Clinton mirror-image of Trump University; but whereas Trump went through the crude motions of offering real-estate training, it is hard to know how exactly Laureate Universities’ “chancellor” Bill Clinton became the highest annually paid academic official in the history of higher education. And what exactly bothered Bill about Laureate in 2015 to cause him suddenly to surrender his chancellor duties that had not bothered him from 2011 to 2014?
Despite the selective moral outrage, the election is about just two things. First, is Trump’s agenda more conservative than Clinton’s, or, inversely, is Clinton’s more liberal than Trump’s? And, second, is either Clinton or Trump so morally flawed, so incompetent, or so inexperienced as to render their policies and platforms irrelevant to their own followers?
Reasonable people can disagree and do, but I think most Americans of all persuasions will conclude that Trump’s positions on the whole are far more conservative than Clinton’s. Tally up Trump’s likely Supreme Court appointments and potential Cabinet choices and collate them with Clinton’s, and there will likely appear an ideological divide that represents traditional conservative/liberal antitheses. Obama raised income taxes and slashed defense spending, and we still will likely have a deficit of $600 billion this year; Hillary’s answer to that paradox is to raise taxes higher. NeverTrump advocates are rightly worried about Trump’s excesses, and for the next four months they will seek to cement the case — even as Hillary’s scandals mount — that Trump’s agenda is no more conservative in toto than Hillary’s, and/or that Trump’s incompetence, corruption, and potential dereliction as president are perhaps far beyond what we have seen in the actual government tenures of Clinton and Obama.
While Trump is loud, reckless, and without political experience (he would be the first president of the republic who had not served in the military or held an elected or appointed federal office), both Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama have done quite a lot of damage by speaking softly, acting deliberately, and drawing on plenty of political experience. I seriously doubt that many Democrats will swear not to sully themselves by voting for a prevaricator and incompetent, and, likewise, I expect by November most Republicans will be ready to “hold their nose” and vote for Trump.
If a “transformative” and “historic” president with an Ivy League law degree, an enthralled media, and “lower the seas and cool the planet” confidence has left us with a world on fire, the veritable destruction of immigration law, $10 trillion in new debt, a wrecked health-care system, a hollowed-out military, racial conflagration, an ossified economy, and near permanent zero interest rates — to the general approval of half the country — then it is hard to get riled up that a more conservative Trump represents something uniquely dangerous.
Like it or not, this election is about degree, relative political agendas, and comparative hazard, not about marrying ideological purity and consistency with sobriety and character — a sad fact that did not enter our politics with Donald J. Trump.
Discussion (19)
Join the conversation. Logged in subscribers avoid the Captcha verification and get priority commenting approvals. No vulgarity, links, or code allowed.
"Damning with faint praise" comes to mind, but at least it is some praise. While not an ivy league lawyer, I believe Trump went to a not inconsequential New York Military Academy, so he is not entirely reckless and inexperienced. Trump uses rhetorical hyperbole and oversimplification for suburb communication - he has explained it clearly himself in the past, if you care to listen. He speaks off the cuff - it may come across as reckless, but I doubt he amassed his wealth and gained many good business partners by being 'reckless'. Not being a globalist does not equal isolationist - national interest is not yet entirely dead - at least in the nationals. "dangerous references to NATO" are no more than NATO countries doing what they promised to do - spend their own money on their defense. In business and in life, you can't strike a fair bargain by telegraphing unconditional agreement.
Trump is an unknown entity, at least in regard to his diplomatic and philosophical positions. He is mouthing about 6 or 8 of the cherished conservative positions. We know what Clinton brings, leftist politics on steroids and deceit. The Supreme Court should be a deal breaker for all Republicans as Trump has committed to jurists who will look at the original intent and the clear language of the Constitution. Let's hope he doesn't change his mind. Clinton, on the other hand, we know will not change her mind on the Court and who she appoints will shred what is left of the document. Let's remember that Trump has run his business successfully and is a capable Chief Executive. It may bring a refreshing change to Federal Agencies, however, the Republican leadership and Congress must be on board to make it so. Some are worried about Trump's Executive Power in the Presidency. Again, if the Congress is doing its job that can be curbed. Trimming the Administrative State and exercising control of the vast bureaucracy can happen if an active Congress chooses to act. I worry about that much more than I worry about Trump being a loose cannon.
No doubt, some of Trump’s flamboyant invective is isolationist, nativist, and protectionist. ...members of Trump’s own party are among his fiercest critics. On cultural matters, I too was disappointed at the plagiarism of lines in Melania Trump’s convention speech and thought her speechwriter should at least have been summarily fired. I am worried about Trump’s flamboyance and about his sloppy and dangerous references to NATO and U.S. foreign commitments. We have already seen the shoot-from-the-hip Trump back down on his idiotic idea of denying all Muslims entry into the U.S. I would prefer Trump to be more socially conservative... I agree that Trump is capable of reckless talk and symbolism... A much-reviled Trump eliminated his primary opponents through invective and character assassination in open debate; NeverTrump advocates are rightly worried about Trump’s excesses... Trump is loud, reckless, and without political experience (he would be the first president of the republic who had not served in the military or held an elected or appointed federal office) There. Fixed it for you.
"Like it or not, this election is about degree, relative political agendas, and comparative hazard, not about marrying ideological purity and consistency with sobriety and character — a sad fact that did not enter our politics with Donald J. Trump." Please tell me when was the last time you saw this in American Presidential politics.
Trump hasn't scared me. I've seen many of his rallies via C-Span or Youtube where he employs a rambling but not incoherent conversational, unscripted delivery and message. Sure, Trump could be a better retail politician and it would be nice if he explains his plan to reduce taxes and regulations and make it affordable for corporations to repatriate $ trillions before he threatens a tax on US employers moving jobs overseas but IMO, he is and has been for some time now, the R candidate most likely to get elected. BTW - in case, these comments are being read, perhaps you Dr. Hansen or one of your Stanford colleagues can answer a few questions I have in regard to US international trade. 1. Do we enjoy free trade or is it about foreign policy designed to forge alliances by providing a US consumer market for developing nations? 2. Is trade policy designed for the benefit of our nation or those of specific business interests? 3. When is it appropriate to enforce the provisions of trade agreements? 4. Should China be allowed to lie, cheat and steal with impunity? 5. Is China a military threat to the United States and if so, is it appropriate to continue a reliance on a trade partner right up until war breaks out. Thank you .
I believe that Mr.Trump said that we should ban Muslims "temporarily" until we can figure out how to vet them properly. I heard the lines in Melania Trumps speech attributed to the First Lady In: 1.My Junior high school graduation 2. My High high school graduation and 3. My college graduation speeches. I've listened to a lot of what Trump says and have come to the conclusion that unlike Obama Trump is in the habit of saying things to the people he works with off the top of his head to get their reactions so that he can further develop his own thoughts. I think that he relies on others opinions and ideas and surrounds himself with creative people who don't always agree with him. I've personally found that to be a much more constructive approach to problem solving than being surrounded by yes men. Unless one is the infallible majesty Barrack Obama I think it's helpful to have a leader who listens to many different ideas. Trumps a bright guy who's thought processes are very different from your run of the mill anyone. I wonder how quickly he will adapt to what passes for thinking with the National media? He has tempered his directness somewhat and I think that he actually changes his thinking as he inputs new data (unlike ....well.... unlike most Liberals)
Professor Victor Davis Hanson, Thank you for your well written and thoughtful essay. Would you consider another one on the possibility of Russian hackers--Putin--blackmailing Hillary Clinton? The FBI investigation alluded to all of HRC's emails being very vulnerable...even the ones she deleted. Best Regards, Rich McEwen
Dear Prof. Hanson, I appreciate your writings. Even handed and well documented. Please consider writing at some point in the future about the relative benefit of Muslim immigrants over Christian immigrants. It seems to me that history has not shown any. (My knowledge base is admittedly limited) You used the strong term "idiotic", in reference to a total ban, but failed to substantiate. What are the historic relative rates of Muslim/Christian immigration? Have they increased? Has past history in other majority Christian countries with Muslim immigration turned out well? It seems to me that the only rational reason to allow immigration is the benefit of the current citizens. I can't think of one benefit of favoring Muslims, who are much less likely to assimilate, over Christians. Hopefully you won't condescend (bore) me with the trite and unsubstantiated "diversity" benefit argument. I fancy myself well read punditry-wise; you are the most qualified to argue this case.
Trump is far more conservative than you let on. Trump is also far more experienced..the right kind of experience than you give him credit for. We are at an inflection point. Socialism must be stopped in this country. Law and order must be established. Taxes must be reduced. ISIS must be defeated. PC crowd must be stopped and put in their place. Trump has the courage and standing to actually take action and face the storm of PC, MSM and Libs screaming to high heaven about default..starving children Killing grandma what ever. Trump has the courage to stare down the democrats at the next government shutdown. Trump will call their bluff. Trump will send non essentially home w/o pay. He will tell the democrats/PC/MSM that he can manage the nations affairs on $3.2 Trillion he does not need $3.8 trillion.. and oh BTW if these employees are non essential why do we have them? The PC people MSM and Democrats will be apoplectic but they will have to come to the table. BTW The wall was passed in 2006 Hillary voted for it.
The Country is corrupt. Career politicians on both sides have been buying votes by pandering to the voters: Raising the debt ceiling time and again, allowing sanctuary cities, illegal immigration, etc. When is it time to fight?! That time has passed and if we do not stand up and fight now, not with votes, as they are useless, but with rifles as did our Founders, then we will eventually fail (as did France, Italy, Spain, Greece, etc.) and there will be a calamitous world war. It is time to march on Washington.
"NeverTrump advocates are rightly worried about Trump’s excesses" The NeoRight are worried that Trump will *win*, and transform the Republican Party from the NeoRight to the Old Right, from globalist, interventionist, and corporatist to nationalist and populist.
"Does any public commentator worry much that Senator Elizabeth Warren’s entire trajectory to Harvard was predicated on her abject and comical lie that she was a rare and sought-after Native American law professor?" Or that she fundamentally betrayed the purported values of "affirmative action" that Leftists profess to uphold?
" I too was disappointed at the plagiarism of lines in Melania Trump’s convention speech and thought her speechwriter should at least have been summarily fired. " Outside of people who think they own ideas and expressions, using someone else's words is called *culture*.
Islam is not a religion. It's a *political system* based on religious principles. The Qur'an openly calls for a specific type of governmental system, namely a religious dictatorship. Therefore, all open Muslims openly support an ideology that unequivocally calls for the destruction of America's governmental system. American immigration law says to bar anyone who's a member of a group calling for our government's destruction from immigrating into our country. This is an overwhelmingly logical and knock-you-over-the-head-obvious policy, if you ask me. How, then, was Trump's call to bar Muslims from immigrating here "idiotic?" I think that he should have gone further, explaining this aspect of Islam, and said that no Muslim should ever be allowed to immigrate here, not just as a temporary thing. This is not true of any other "religion," as far as I know, as only Islam openly calls for a clear governmental system. Also, I urge you to Google some time how first cousin marriage is encouraged and often arranged within Islam (apparently, Muhammad did it), making almost 50% of Muslims worldwide inbred. If you go back a few generations, that makes almost 100% of Muslims either inbred themselves or second or third generation descendants of inbred people. Then, I'd urge you to look up the effects of being born to first cousins, from much lower IQ to physical and psychological defects. I'd then be quite interested to hear one try to explain how allowing in people of this background would be helpful to our country. Look for the left to start calling people who point this out racist.
Brilliant. Right on in every respect. I couldn't agree more but as a hard-core Conservative who worked on the Goldwater campaign and the Reagan campaign, I am not working on the Trump campaign and I will not be voting for Donald Trump. Everything you write is true; I totally agree. But, all everything you cite means is that America's best days are behind US and our future days are numbered and it's a small number. It makes no difference who wins this election. The next President isn't going to change anything. Nobody is going to step up and save US. But I simply can't vote for Trump because I think he's NUTS
Truly disappointed in your analysis of Mr Trump. You still have not discussed your views on the desire by the establishment (of which both a "sober and judicious" Jeb Bush and Hillary Clinton are kin) to lie, cheat and steal their way to another win for their Presidential candidate at the expense of blue collar working men and women. Trump seemingly is as honest a candidate this country has ever seen. Why the dismissal of his rhetoric which seems to be obviously an attempt to get the attention of the media and the electorate. You seem to be oblivious about his strategy in spending as little of his money and his donor's dollars as possible by utilizing social media to get his messages across for free. Very well thought out. His choice of a social conservative for VP and his speech should have been the "tell" for your "concerns" about Trump's ability to make very good, thoughtful decisions. He's answered every question about his bonafides as a thoughtful American leader. You on the other hand have a wall up to acceptance of these points.
It would appear that you are coming around to the idea of a Trump presidency. But before we leave the POTUS issue, you implied that Obama had served in the military. If you indeed did write that be advised that Obama has never served in the military. Let me cut to my current conclusion about the issue of whose leadership should be selected for POTUS. It won't be popular but my continuous examination of the issues for America leads me to conclude that the “problem” for the USA is that the current value, moral and political differences are permanently “intractable” in the population and not available to solution in the usual way of compromise. All the arguments have been made in the past months in the USA with millions of words, many of them volatile and heated words, exchanged between the people mired down in this deeply divided nation. All that needs to be said, has been said and by now, everybody has had a chance to speak their mind. It should be clear to all by now that political compromise has been, and will continue to be, impossible in the US. Now all that remains is that quiet wait until the dawn so the actual war can begin... At bottom line, nobody is going to "unify" our country. The basic moral and value differences in the current divided US population are simply too great. What we really require is someone or some system that will allow the US to "Balkanize" in an effective and organized manner and try and avoid a second US Civil War.
Nailed it!
Vote TRUMP. Lets avoid serfdom.