Archive

The Power of Media Ignorance

The Power of Media Ignorance

Victor Davis Hanson // National Review

Almost two weeks ago I offered at NRO a few synopses of various theories about why California — which, for a variety of reasons, had seemed so ripe for a New York–style epidemic — had nonetheless strangely been exempt at least for a while from the virus’s spread. I included the pedestrian possibility of some previously acquired “herd immunity,” given the state’s singular exposure from November to January 31 to direct flights from China, including those from Wuhan, and initial CDC and media reports last year of an unusually early and severe assumed flu hitting the state.

Within a few days, I was hit by media inquiries and private calls asking about my ongoing “coronavirus antibody testing studies.”

Despite ad nauseam corrections that I had never claimed in the NRO article or elsewhere to be a doctor, much less an epidemiologist or a conductor of any such study, and that the Hoover Institution is not a medical school, the fake news still spread.

I got dozens more calls and emails from private citizens who thought they had the virus and wanted confirmation of that supposed fact, in order to venture out and help others with antibodies. Some said they wanted “in” immediately.

Others called saying they were scared that they had an unknown illness and wanted confirmation of what it had been.

And some were from Chinese media sources wanting such “lab” confirmation that earlier herd immunity developing in California pre-2020 was the final proof needed of an American origin, rather than a later Chinese genesis of the virus. (Oddly they apparently assumed that if any such future study were to show some sizable herd immunity in California, and thereby suggest an earlier outbreak than what was assumed in late January 2020, it would not mean the Chinese were lying about the first dates of the infection. Would the Chinese media wish to explain why flights from Wuhan to the U.S. were open throughout January when, for mysterious reasons, the Chinese themselves had blocked travel earlier than the ban from Wuhan to other parts of China?)

Read the full article here

Share This
VDH’s Blade of Perseus

About VDH’s Blade of Perseus

View Full Bio →

Discussion (4)

Join the conversation. Logged in subscribers avoid the Captcha verification and get priority commenting approvals. No vulgarity, links, or code allowed.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RF Lmnt 7 years ago

"You see, Maria, the world is run by 'practical' people: that is to say, by people who do not know how to think, have never had any education in thinking, and who do not wish to have it. They get on far better with lies, tub thumping, swindling, vote catching, murdering, and the rest of practical politics. So, when a person who can think does come along, to tell them what they are doing wrong, or how to put it right, they have to invent some way of slinging mud at him, for fear of losing their power and being forced to do the right thing." "Mistress Masham's Repose", T. H. White. (1946)

Geoff Tasker 7 years ago

Regarding the word - “Hamartia”: With the entry of Donald Trump into the ‘presidential’ primary 2016, there was a feeling that this unconventional individual had breeched a realm where he didn’t belong and then again, perhaps he did belong under special circumstances. It wasn’t until Professor Hanson provided the ‘Tragic Hero’ concept in his book - “The Case for Trump”, with his chapter 11 with historical perspective, did the ‘aw..hah!’ moment fall into place. This ‘aw..hah’ moment motivated me to go back and read Thomas Sowell’s book - “Intellectuals and Society”. It became clear once again the “Anointed Vision” of the unconstrained; the intellectuals and the intelligentsia would continue in recurrent and consistently ideological diatribe to diminish and destroy our Cosmic Hero. Since the ‘progressives’ for two centuries have dismissed God, diminished evil, thus dismissed morality and established that individual ‘desires’ are really individual ‘rights’, the unrelenting ‘Anointed View’ is hell bent on destroying anything cosmic, anything traditional with evolutionary empirical evidence to justify our sound judgement going forward. Our President understands this and will persist in his boundless energy to beat back this wave of the “The Road to Serfdom”. We should all be thankful for President Trump, but when some believe in the Enlightenment from the ‘left’ and others believe in Enlightenment from the ‘right’ the epic battle will continue. In addition the words of an ethereal figure in history: “Forgive them Father, they know not what they do”, will forever haunt us. And so it goes.

David Saenz 7 years ago

Very Interesting analysis. Hopefully more dialog to follow.

Andrew Simons 7 years ago

I just watched GoodFellows 4.15.20. I'm in shock! To see this group all patting each other on the back at the Hoover Institution has me terrified. Clearly I'm not understanding something.