Victor Davis Hanson // Defining Ideas
Hillary Clinton seems to be experiencing a strange, slow motion meltdown following her 2016 loss to Donald Trump. Recently, she sent out a Twitter video message, recorded on her cellphone camera, with advice to feminists: “And let me just say, this is directed to the activist bitches supporting bitches. So let’s go.” At about the same time, she appeared at the Grammy Awards, via a video, reading a snippet about Trump’s fast-food eating habits from Michael Wolff’s widely discredited book, Fire and Fury.
Before Clinton ran against Trump, she was considered a cautious Democratic politician, albeit with a dubious ethical record. Yet after she tangled with Trump, she seems to be suffering mysterious after-effects. Call it radiation sickness from Trump’s toxic gamma rays. Translated, that means orthodox politicians often lose when they try dueling with the unorthodox Trump on his terms—and then, making matters worse, they end up doubling down with more emotional heat.
Early on during the Republican primary, a conventional wisdom developed in the media and within political circles that it was suicidal to engage in ad hominem exchanges with Trump. The mainstream media meant that assessment as no compliment to Trump. Journalists sneered that the showboating Trump had fourteen years of experience in repartee and ad hoc invective on his reality television hit show The Apprentice. They also conceded that Trump had long ago learned that, in the dog-eat-dog world of New York real estate, and in the nasty gossip of Manhattan’s celebrity scene, going on the preemptive offensive is a deterrence strategy, crude or not. In such a landscape, gentlemanly forbearance was not interpreted as magnanimity to be appreciated but as weakness to be exploited.
Furthermore, in 2016, part of Trump’s message was that an overrated coastal elite played by stuffy rules of comportment to hide both their incompetence and hypocrisies. For Trump, the best way of radiating the establishment was saying anything to anyone at any time anywhere—especially by inventing schoolyard nicknames that savagely captured an opponent’s perceived weaknesses and flaws—and begged for a reply in kind.
The media’s analyses of Trump’s style were true enough. But the pundits forgot a few other key reasons why the radioactive Trump melted his opponents. In every one of Trump’s jousts, he was coiled and reactive—a fact known to his base who defended Trump’s fallout on the basis of ‘they started it, he finished it.”
Second, Trump’s personal invective was part of a larger assault on institutions and their representatives who were increasingly perceived both as hostile to half the U.S. population and hypocritically self-interested. Because there was merit in his coarse criticism, Trump’s opponents found themselves reactively defending the scarcely defensible. Being outraged at Trump often led them mistakenly to be outraged at his policies.
Republican establishment favorite Jeb Bush traded one-on-one jabs with Trump and was politically demolished as “low-energy Jeb,” unable to stand the thermonuclear heat of the Trump bombs. Bush went out as if he were a whiney losing aspirant on Celebrity Apprentice without understanding why his agenda never resonated with the conservative and increasingly populist base. A suave Marco Rubio descended to joust with Trump on relative hand size. He ended up cruelly tagged as “little Marco.” The boisterous rhetorician Ted Cruz duked it out Trump-style after Trump slandered his family. He ended up the sneering sobriquet “lying Ted Cruz.” So it went in all of Trump’s duels, from his clashes with Megan Kelly to those with “crooked Hillary.” Even his disheveled insider Steven Bannon finally earned the sobriquet “sloppy Steve” when he appeared to turn on his former boss. The careers of none of these people improved after unaccustomedly going nuclear with Trump
Conventional wisdom warns Trump that his retaliatory attacks are not presidential; that they are no longer needed now that he’s in the Oval Office; that they are counterproductive; and that they turn off Independent voters, especially Independent women whom Trump will need in 2018 and perhaps 2020.
The counter-argument?
Before Trump, politicians observed Marquis of Queensberry rules of comportment while they ran up $20 trillion in national debt, left the border unsecured with 11-15 million illegal aliens residing with impunity in the United States, failed to achieve significant economic growth in over a decade, saw middle-class incomes ossify, and could not translate interventions abroad into strategic victories, while allowing North Korea to develop nuclear ballistic missiles.
Globalization before 2016 was seen only as a positive gift. It certainly was often salutary for most in the world—but not always for many Americans. Received wisdom held that outsourcing and offshoring were good for the American economy. Meanwhile, companies fled the United States. More regulations and bigger government seemed fated. Free trade de facto was considered fair. Trade deficits like budget deficits were nothing much to worry about—even as middle-class wages stagnated, the red-state interior was deindustrialized, and the victims were written off as losers, deplorables, irredeemables, and clingers who foolishly had not prepared themselves for the coastal “knowledge based” economy of the “information age.”
In response, half the country—the more important electoral-college half—felt that the way politicians had treated their middle-class, post-industrial malaise was insincere and merely palliative. Then Trump came along and offered searing radiation treatments designed to kill the metastases shortly before it poisoned the rescued host—by loudly promoting seemingly archaic ideas like bringing back capital and jobs from abroad, deregulating the economy, lowering taxes, and making the United States more fossil-fuel independent.
Something similar happened abroad. Most of the world’s signature establishment institutions beneath the veneer of their polite nomenclature and mannered protocols were ethically, or at least administratively, compromised. The United Nations often proved itself to be an anti-American, anti-Western, anti-Semitic, and anti-democratic organization, masquerading in tony Manhattan as the voice of global morality, subsidized by the American hosts it routinely attacked. The European Union was evolving into an anti-democratic statist project warped by German mercantilism and German cultural and political dominance on matters of finance, immigration, and foreign policy that brooked no dissent. Postwar NATO members had mostly ignored their commitment to spend 2 percent of their respective GDP on defense to share the burdens of defending Europe more equitably. Europeans had come to assume that protecting Europe was more important to Americans than it was to Europeans. The point is not that these heralded institutions are unnecessary or incapable of reform. Rather, to change they often need the sort of toxic criticism that Trump levels because they have consistently ignored more polite and diplomatic badgering from world leaders.
The media stereotype of Trump is that he is a crude adolescent narcissist. He is eager for even superficial pats on the head, while morose and brooding at even the slightest criticism. The more pessimistic appraisals paint Trump as an utter nihilist—a wild elephant thrashing mindlessly about, destroying custom and tradition in his midst.
But Trump is also more than a needy egoist or anarchist. Like it or not, he sees himself on a “make America great” crusade that entails radically redefining American tax policy, the regulatory federal octopus, immigration enforcement, trade protocols, the fairness of the international order, the transparency of media coverage—and the very language and manners in which past pathologies were downplayed. His tweets, his televised rallies, and his blunt press-conference repartee share that common theme: What the establishment calls normal and salutary is abnormal and toxic, and the only way to treat the cancer is with radiation—at least until the medicine kicks in, the patient improves, and voters see tangible improvements in their daily lives.
Most of the elite write Trump’s message off entirely because they perceive him as toxic. But the more interesting moral and intellectual question is why more polite politicians did not do much, or never much worried, about the hollowed-out interior of post-industrial America, the effect of illegal immigration on entry-level job wages, or the deleteriousness of the growing federal regulatory bureaucracy on struggling small businesses and individual freedom.
Why didn’t a more gentlemanly candidate such as Mitt Romney speak about “our” miners, “our” vets, and “our” farmers, or a more mellifluous president Barack Obama of bringing back American jobs to the post-industrial wasteland, or a more cerebral candidate Hillary Clinton of helping West Virginian coal miners recalibrate their industry? Romney was certainly polite and mannered when he reminded wealthy donors at a private gathering that 47 percent of the country would never vote for him because almost half of Americans believed they were “entitled to health care, to food, to housing, to you-name-it.” Presidential candidate Obama was once poised and steady as he explained to liberal elites in San Francisco that he lost the Pennsylvania primary because of mostly backward xenophobic clingers who were gun- and bible-crazed. Hillary thought she was calm and professional as she wrote off a quarter of the nation as “deplorables” and “irredeemables.”
Morality can be defined in a variety of ways. For half the country, rude empathy in 2016 proved preferable to polite dissimulation. Of course, it would always be preferable if empathetic messages were delivered by empathetic messengers. But often they are not. And so voters then made the necessary adjustments—and often allowances.
A final thought. Trump’s radioactive invective left enemies on the campaign trail, and during his first-year efforts to enact his agenda, in a permanent meltdown. To the degree he pivots occasionally and lets his solid policies speak for themselves, his still seared and exasperated enemies nonetheless remain permanently red-hot—even as Trump seems to be cooling down and reasonable. Patients usually do not keep damning the side-effects of past therapy once their health improves, but rather slowly begin to acknowledge its utility.
Discussion (25)
Join the conversation. Logged in subscribers avoid the Captcha verification and get priority commenting approvals. No vulgarity, links, or code allowed.
Hello! I could have sworn I’ve been to this blog before but after going through a few of the articles I realized it’s new to me. Anyways, I’m certainly happy I found it and I’ll be book-marking it and checking back regularly!
Brillante y radioactivo artículo! Gracias.
Spot on article. Trump's public persona has always been the guy in charge, the one who tells other people "you're fired," and he learned a lot from professional wrestling. In the debates he was willing to blurt out when it wasn't his turn with one-liners that hit the mark, and he put his opponents on edge and made them play his game. But ultimately I think he really believes in his brand, and he has made his brand America, and on the surface level that can seem trite but if you did down into patriotism you're talking about "our vets" and "our police force" who protect us and "our families" and "our workers" all of whom we should protect. It's the cynicism of the political elites that they see only the surface and they do think it's trite.
As for his effects on Hillary, this much I want to say: Yes, thou shalt know, spite of thy past Distress, And all those Ills which thou so long hast mourn'd; Heav'n has no Rage, like Love to Hatred turn'd, Nor Hell a Fury, like a Woman scorn'd. (William Congreve, 1697)
Yes sir, true dat!
Trump as run up the debt with his tax cuts for the rich.
This is as an excellent summary of all the salient factors that led to Trump’s election. In fact, it is one of the best I have encountered in a very long timr. An actual studied treatment that will be a shock to those who think American white racists and Russian exploitation of American tendencies not to fact check online ads was the true cause of the election results.
Hello Professor, Beautiful analysis! You nailed it! Thanks and keep it up. markm
Trump also had the brilliance to figure out what the two key needs of the Middle Class were and then gave it to them in the tax cut bill of 2017; namely, income growth and JOBS.
You forgot to mention that Trump has assaulted many women and that he lies or hyperbolates every 2nd or 3rd sentence. You forgot to mention that he has done nothing to respond to and to stop cyber attacks on our country by a major adversary, Russia, and that Trump is attempting to subvert our democratic institutions. You obviously don’t give a hoot about the environment as I assume you support the reckless actions that Pruitt and Trump have taken to run ripshod over the land air and water. Hitler revved up the economy and national pride - at what cost? Have you no shame? You actually support this vile creature of a president who once punched his fifth grade teacher in the face and who has cheated on every one of his three wives and many of his partners and suppliers in business? Trump can die and burn in Hell and you can join him there!
Excellent analysis, Mr. Hanson. This piece fits well as a counterpart with your earlier NR article about the reasons why the FBI/DOJ leaders thought they were immune from retribution for their nefarious actions (i.e. no punishments and possibly rewards after Hillary was elected). I think Mr. Trump may be as much a serendipitous beneficiary of a change to the American mindset as much as a catalyst of the same. Either way he comes out winning. P.S., I'm loving "The Second World Wars" but am not very far into it yet. I'm reading it in conjunction with "Mapping the Second World War" by Peter Chasseaud, and I think it makes a nice complement (but it slows my progress).
This is some of, if not the most powerful and beautiful use of the language I have ever read, as well as brilliant observation of the facts as they were.
Hi Victor, Thanks, great article and analogy. Looking at President Trump from a historical POV, he has appeared on the political map at a time when we, the great unwashed masses, need his radioactive style. In colonial America multiple men appeared and against the odds asserted independence, fought and won a war with the world's superpower, wrote the single most important document ever in human history for living free and constituted a government from it. Thereafter Andrew Jackson came along to end the founding father cartel. Abraham Lincoln appeared to end slavery and prevent the splitting of the Union. Teddy Roosevelt was adventurous and saw the natural geographic beauty to establish the National Parks before loggers/miners could ravage these treasures. Harry Truman took office by default of FDR's death and saved millions of lives by dropping the bombs on Japan. Ronald Reagan took us out of the economic malaise, righted foreign policy failures, ended the Cold War, liberated the assimilated satellite countries of the USSR to put America on a strong footing forward. And now Donald Trump, political outsider, was elected against the wishes and predictions of the pundits. The Ruling Class (Angelo Codevilla) have risen into ever more powerful orbits in government since LBJ's early 1960's Great Society push. Good intention Democrats have evolved to become present day Marxists by using intimidation, judicial appointments, academia, news media, victim groups and unconstitutional actions to push the ideology, divide and conquer the electorate and to eliminate the opposition. Post Reagan Republicans have been the enablers. And now we fortunately have Donald Trump. His radioactive style is strength. The multi tentacle opposition senses weakness and seizes upon it for gain. They hate his push back, his tweeting, calling out the fake news, ejecting Sam Donaldson like reporters, calling out the Russian investigation for what is; Trump attacks from the high ground. This Republican is supposed to acquiesce and take it from all their attack points like his predecessors did. What's wrong with him? Dementia? Delusional? Low IQ? Too much McDonalds? What we are witnessing is the Reaganesque strength of a man who would be POTUS. Here at a time and place to stop the march away from the principles of the US Constitution with profligate spending, politicized justice system, politicized IRS, politicized EPA, and a business regulatory juggernaut. Trump's strength, his radioactivity, his leadership, his push back against the ruling class is what's needed now to get the US back to government by the people, of the people and for the people instead of the present government modus operandi of over the people.
Trump appelle un chat un chat et cela nous fait un bien fou.
Let's just hope the "deep state" doesn't find a way to completely destroy democracy, by it's false narrative against President Trump, before he has a chance to put the ship back on course. I have been, and to a degree, continue to be, unconvinced that Trump is a conservative, but I have to admit that his actions have all been far better than any President in years. Certainly no one can argue that he practices "identity politics." He stands behind his America First words.
Spot on as usual. BRILLIANT!
Interesting article. Thanks for your good work over the years.
Dear Mr. Hanson, I am one of President Trump's voters. I saw in him a determination to be president. He didn't need to earn notoriety by becoming president, he was already famous. And he was fearless. I thought: Trump is a different kind of president who isn't involved in politics; who sees what's wrong in our government and our country and wants to fix it. The political elites saw it as a joke. He would never win. In their minds, just ridiculing Trump was enough to get him laughed off the stage. I saw him as a breath of fresh air. Better to have a business man running the show than a politician who would dish out more of the same failed policies we've seen for the past 20+ years. If those of us who defended him and voted for him continue to stand by him, he could become one of our greatest presidents. I'm predicting he will. Imagine having to deal with Schumer and Pelosi for 8 years!
I always enjoy listening to your lectures on YouTube and reading your posts/articles. Everything you say are wise, sincere, balanced and thoughtful. I wish there were more people with your knowledge and insight. Thank you for sharing your intelligent and wonderful mind with the rest of us.
Dear Professor, I notice that the generally accepted number of illegal aliens in the country is beginning to creep up. What WAS 11 million people has now set as 11-15 million. For what it's worth, my general estimation has been much closer to 25-30 million. I wonder who will be proven right? Jesus Bortoni
It is disappointing to read in a VDH essay that Hillary Clinton is characterized as 'cerebral'. Whatever else she is, she is not possessed of a keen mind. She was clumsy as a lawyer, mindless as First Lady of both Arkansas and America in her acquisitiveness, and maladroit as a two-time candidate for the presidency. Nothing in the books whose authorship is ascribed to her hints that they are the outpourings of a subtle, well-educated thinker. In this essay ( 'Radioactive Trump' ), she might better have been characterized as 'haughty' than as 'cerebral'.
As close to historically accurate as any future researcher will ever find on this moment.
Well done again, you have a very good understanding of the Trump phenom. Most other observers and media are missing the Trumpian picture, they are entirely focused on the minutia and the form of what he says and does rather than the content. My background, immigrant from the Middle East, well educated, Muslim raised, well off, would have me pegged as a resistance member and a Hillary voter but I went with Trump. I wasn't alone, most people that I knew also went with Trump. I suspect we will see more of the same in the next election unless Trump self implode as he is wont to do. Good work.
V.D.H:great article....! POTUS does "Radiate" nuclear vibes...any competitor would be "Wacky" to go Word-to-word with DT on any stage....He is a "Hydrogen" bomb. Paul Herriott
I've also heard those who try to take President Trump on and lose as having won their "Trump Tattoo".