Archive

Is Trump an Island?

Is Trump an Island?

by Victor Davis Hanson // National Review

 

If Trump would let his deeds speak for themselves, he would quiet his enemies far more than he does with Twitter broadsides.

No man is an island entire of itself;

every man is a piece of the continent, a part of the main . . .

And therefore never send to know for whom

the bell tolls; it tolls for thee.

— John Donne

The pathological hatred of Donald Trump — from impeachment votes to the emoluments-clause suits to assassination chic to talk of invoking 25th Amendment to sexual-harassment writs — would grind down almost any 71-year-old man. Trump may be ego-driven and have a proverbially thin skin, but even a rhino would finally chafe under the 24/7 media detestation of his person, his family, and his presidency.

Someday soon now, we will look back at the Russian-collusion psychodrama, the strange transference of his transition team’s emails to Robert Mueller, the Clinton role in the Steele-Fusion GPS dossier, the destruction of journalistic integrity, and the slant of the Mueller investigation team and appreciate that we were living through an effort to swing the 2016 election and, failing that, a veritable slow-motion effort to remove an elected presidency.

The ubiquitous Lisa Bloom, we learn, was attempting to arrange payments for, or at least merchandise the testimonies of, supposed Trump harassment victims in the waning days of the 2016 campaign. Both liberal and conservative surveys of the media reveal that at least 90 percent of Trump coverage has been negative. Those who once held positions now held by Trump disown them; what they used to oppose, they now embrace — the only constant being whatever Trump is against, they are for.

Fake news will not stop. The rewards among peers and the media profession for getting a whack to Trump are felt worth the costs of largely betraying the cannons of journalism. A generation ago, a Brian Ross — twice now caught trafficking in untruths — would have been through as a journalist. Today, he is merely suspended as a temporary casualty in the noble war against Trump evil.

Some of Trump’s current isolation is unavoidable, nearly half of the voting public backed a Steppenwolf Trump to do what he is doing: drop the Sunnybrook Farm rules of past failed Republican nominees, brawl with the identity-politics Democrats, and smack the swamp Republicans. The deplorables wanted strong chemotherapy to excise Washington malignancies and had no illusions that such medicine, to work, can always be pleasant.

In addition, voters may talk grandly of wanting change, but they recoil when it actually begins. And if once wanting the Obama agenda to fail was considered proof of near treason and racism, working to ensure that the entire Trump presidency is aborted just months after the election has been recalibrated as patriotic progressive activism.

The result is that Trump is now an island in Washington. Fewer Republican officeholders want on his team. In the past, even beleaguered presidents could turn to a network of stalwarts in and out of politics. Not Trump.

When George W. Bush’s popularity dipped below 30 percent in most polls, he at least could count on the money and support of the diehard Republican congressional delegations, the traditional big donors of the Republican party, the conservative media — National Review, Commentary, The Weekly Standard, the Wall Street Journal — grassroots local and state politicians, senior Republican statesman, and “wise men” retired politicians.

Trump’s Republican critics have cultural prejudices against the Trump phenomena or they recoil from Trump’s behavior or they understandably enjoy belated nemesis repaying prior Trump hubris.

Trump has no party, no organized supporters. Depending on the polls, he hovers around favorability ratings of 39-40 percent.

His thin Republican majority in the Senate just got thinner with the defeat of Roy Moore in Alabama. Given four or five Republican senators who either hate Trump’s guts or despise his agenda, he really cannot rely on the Senate to pass his legislation — at least, unless his popularity hits 45 percent, or senators find his agenda resonating in their states, or if, against the odds, he picks up more Senate seats in the 2018 midterm elections.

Many of the big Republican donors opposed Trump in the primary. While they privately applaud his Reaganesque menu, they do so in the shadows — given the social opprobrium that Trump still incurs in their country-club circles.

Never Trump Republicans, who heretofore could not sway voters, nonetheless still dominate conservative commentary — growing quiet during a week of good economic news, becoming loud when an especially embarrassing Trump tweet or a Roy Moore loss prompts another “I told you so” sermon. To have once opposed Trump, but now to serve in his administration for the good of the country earns the honorable the cheap smear “Vichy Republicans.”

Ex-Republican presidents and past failed presidential candidates want no part of Trump — in a fashion never seen before in modern political history. George H. W. Bush was proud that he voted for Hillary Clinton. George W. Bush did not vote for either major-party candidate in the last election. Mitt Romney was on record as not voting for Trump. It is likely that John McCain did not either.

Most of the Washington-New York Republican “swamp,” the establishment veterans of past State and Defense Departments and the National Security Council are not in Trump’s corner at best. At worst, they pontificate in op-eds that Trump’s brashness and crudity will destroy the 70-year post-war bipartisan foreign policy as we know it. Often, Republican senators come out against Trump legislation at the eleventh hour to play spoilers, still teeth-gnashing over their prior spats with candidate Trump.

In sum, Trump has no margin of error, no fallback support, not a single “give the president the benefit of the doubt” concession from anyone. “Just desserts,” “payback’s a b****,” “he had it coming” are the usual exegeses.

Trump, in response, tweets down. In abrasive Curtis LeMay or uncouth George S. Patton style, he is determined to allow his enemy’s stereotypes to warp appreciation of his record. In his defiant Promethean isolation, Trump will not let his accomplishments speak for themselves without duking it out with an ankle-biting Joe Scarborough or passive-aggressive Kirsten Gillibrand. In that sense, Trump is both the proverbial castle-builder and the inrushing surf: His undeniable successes no sooner start to widen his 40 percent base than Trump’s killer waves of electronic feuding wash them away.

Nonetheless, an embattled Trump still retains his undeniable cunning, his superhuman energy, his insight into human nature, and an uncanny instinct that his bold agenda will strike a chord with 51 percent of the American people — if he will just let it resonate on its own merits. Fighting back against existential enemies ensures deterrence; but fighting empty suits does not.

What is ahead as we enter the 2018 midterms?

Trump will win support from his growing number of achievements on the home front: economic news on the upswing, illegal immigration down, superfluous regulations dropped, energy production up, unemployment and interest rates low, with consumer confidence and the stock market high.

Abroad, the Mattis-McMaster-Pompeo-Haley-Tillerson team has stabilized U.S. foreign policy and avoided both Obama recessional apologetics and optional warring and nation-building. ISIS is now in full retreat. Israel and the Gulf states are once again friends. China and North Korea are shocked that the U.S. is no longer appeasing.

Call it what you wish — “principled realism” or neo-Jacksonianism — the Trump doctrine fits the current mood of the country. Friends abroad believe the U.S. is now more reliable; enemies fear it is dangerously unpredictable.

The point is that Trump’s policies are mostly on the right track, both for the country and for his own political supporters. Never Trumpers quietly acknowledge that never has there been a more active and successful effort to appoint young, unapologetically conservative federal judges — absolutely inconceivable had Hillary Clinton been president.

Trump is also fortunate in his enemies. The Democratic party cannot calm its identity-politics frenzies. No sooner had Alabamian Doug Jones squeaked by than he began his victory speech by thanking his supporters by tribe — as if they were a series of hyphenated collectives rather than unique individuals.

Antifa, the take-a-knee embarrassment, the iconoclasm craziness, and the meltdown of progressive sexual harassers are reminders to purple-state America that there is no longer a Democratic worker party of Truman and JFK. Instead, the party is a collage of rich and poor zealots, who agree on despising the deplorable middle class. The Sanders agenda would result in slow, if any, economic growth, and endless French-style squabbling over thinning slices of a shrinking pie.

The Mueller investigators — drawn most from a pool of Obama and Clinton partisans and weighed heavily from Mueller’s own law firm — are reifying most Trump blunderbuss allegations of the last year.

The special legal team each week finds a new way to prove that its lawyers are not disinterested, but instead left-wing and pro-Clinton. The liberal-heralded “dream team” and “army” of “all stars” has proved so far puerile in their text messaging and emailing, and arrogant in ignoring their own conflicts of interests. They increasingly are turning to the tentacles of the deep-state octopus to help strangle Trump.

Mueller himself apparently saw no ethical problem in hiding for months the fact that both Peter Strzok and Lisa Page had been taken off his investigation for professional improprieties. He thus left the misleading impression that their abrupt departures were instead more or less routine and certainly not connected.

The entire special-counsel agenda was flawed from the outset because it was based on two bogus assumptions: one, that the fraudulent Fusion GPS dossier was a key to opening the door to a dark room of collusion, and, two, that it was wise to round up Washington-New York liberal deep-state partisans to outmaneuver the novice Trump. In truth, the Steele binder was a toxic Tolkien ring that has corrupted everyone who sought to use it.

In a normal world of judging achievement, even with a biased media, Trump’s popularity should be at least 50 percent

Yet the great enigma of our age is Trump himself. He no sooner in unorthodox fashion wins praise for against-the-odds boldness — exposing the media as ethically bankrupt, pulling out from the Paris climate accord, moving the U.S. embassy to Jerusalem, taking on the entire NFL and revealing its absurdities — than he erodes his own very achievement with raging Twitter outbursts against non-entities or a needless slap at one of his own appointees or a thin-skin boast that he was really right after all.

How odd that Trump’s achievements starve the anti-Trump media reptile and reduce it to hissing about his ice cream or soda consumption, even as Trump’s tweets only give it a new exoskeleton.

The irony is that Trump need not outshout his critics. He meets the press frequently and is far more candid and accessible than Barack Obama ever was. His inner team relies on more women — Conway, Sanders, Hicks — than did the prior administration. Trying to revive the forgotten cast-offs of globalization is far more moral than writing them off as losers, deplorables, and clingers.

His cabinet officers have far more authority and latitude than any in recent memory and are certainly more outspoken about their boss than were Obama’s obsequious subordinates. Trump has mostly on substantive issues proved his Never Trump critics wrong (his agenda is more conservative than any since Reagan’s) and left his liberal opponents unhinged, who rightly sense that he seeks to undo the entire eight-year Obama agenda in four years.

In sum, would Trump let his deeds speak for themselves, he would quiet his enemies far more than he does with Twitter broadsides.

In the prior eight years, Obama tried to invent achievement through soaring rhetoric about what he could never do. Trump seems just intent to diminish in tweets all that he has already accomplished in deeds.

But no man is an island, and to press on, Trump needs to allow allies of his agenda to become allies of himself.

 

Share This
VDH’s Blade of Perseus

About VDH’s Blade of Perseus

View Full Bio →

Discussion (14)

Join the conversation. Logged in subscribers avoid the Captcha verification and get priority commenting approvals. No vulgarity, links, or code allowed.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sandy Kramer 9 years ago

Regarding Hanson's column, "Is Trump an Island": Welcome to the closet, 2018. Homosexuals are ubiquitous. And Trump supporters seek to be hidden.

JoeF. 9 years ago

This is an excellent piece-as usual-but I would like to point out that there is a very good reason why President Trump refuses to refrain from his constant tweeting. As much as I find the tone--if not the substance--of his tweets cringe-inducing , I'm positive that Trump believes that if he doesn't brag of his achievements --the media won't report them. If he remains silent, his "good" deeds will go unreported. One of the most frustrating things to watch was George W. Bush remaining silent in the face of a daily and unyielding onslaught of attacks by his political and media enemies Trump is not going to make the same mistake.

howard golden 9 years ago

Prof. Hanson, Your erudite writing and impeccable logic attracted me so much I bought a few of your books. Your advice to Pres. Trump is spot on as is your analysis of the issues here and with Israel and with so many other matters. The rants against you usually seem to be, as you accurately point out, mainly ad hominem attacks. When I am challenged for a position contrary to the accepted group think, I always do as you do - ask the critic, or Obama supporter to refute what I have said or written. They can't do it. It seems that support for Obama is based on his personality not his actions and on Trump it is the opposite, the attack is on his personality which overshadows his actual actions. Shame. I don't like Donald and have not liked him for over 25 years from the time I encountered him in NY. HOWEVER I admit that many of his positions resonate with me. I have friends from Czech, Hungary, Malta, Slovakia, France etc. who would like to come to the US but despite their quite impressive credentials, the process to get in to the US is a 50% incline (i.e. very steep) and both time consuming and embarrassing (to me as a US citizen). Why should those who circumvent the process and are 'undocumented' be given amnesty just because the 'only want a better life for their children" or "we need people to cut our lawns and peel potatoes and clean dishes in restaurants'. Why not protect US borders? One of the legal qualifications in international law to be called a nation is the ability to control one's borders. We need immigration but I don't see why the US shouldn't be able to take the best and brightest rather than whomever is able to sneak in? Why not fight for a better deal with NAFTA? The Iran deal is totally flawed and Obama pulled a fast one on Congress to get it passed, as we are now finding out. It supported the main source of terrorism in the world just so he could have a 'signature accomplishment'. I recall the last time a leader came home with 'peace in our time' and fear that it has happened again. I also found it very interesting when I point out to friends and acquaintances that Obama started the use of Executive Order to 'get things done' and also circumvented the Constitution quite often the response was - perhaps he did but it was the 'right thing". However Mr. Obama claims to have taught constitutional law at Harvard, (he taught first year students in a introductory course no other professor wanted to teach) so I believe it is quite instructive that the US Supreme Court unanimously voted against the Obama government position 10 times and reversed his personal NLRB appointment by that same majority. etc. While many cases were started under the prior president, Obama had the right, which he often exercised, to tell the justice dept not to appeal or to support an appeal. Does anyone remember Obama personally directing not to prosecute Black Panthers who stood outside a polling station and intimidated voters, called the worst case many in the Justice Dept have ever seen? Or that a few attorney resigned over that instruction? Obama reserved for himself to "do the right thing" that he believed to be right and disregarded the law quite often. I think you wrote on this also - if one side or the other believes this is the 'right thing' then the means are less important than getting it done - unless it is Trump. Personally I am more worried about what the Left in the US will do to our country than what the radical right can pull off. The Left controls newspapers, TV news and most of the top positions in the Universities. (Unlike canard that "the Jews control the world" I believe this can be and IS supported by voting records and donations etc.) Whether one likes Trump or hates him, it was Obama who 'created" him and gave him the clear path to the White House. Again, another point you have exposed. I hope you get other letters of support since you seem to only publish the "angry Reader" notes which are so often childish screeds. There are many who appreciate you and your logical thinking and succinct writing. I wish you a long life and a healthy New Year. Best wishes, Howard Golden

jesse corbett 9 years ago

Very valid points. While I would love to pull an Alice Kramden and give him an "aww shaddup!", my two cent opinion is a reason that even if he could shut up, he dare not. To the point, if his offensive line cannot handle crap from the quarterback, it is time for a new offensive line. Voting records and whining give evidence more than a few are willing to let the defense sneak in and go for a quarterback sack. I say burn out the impurities! If they cannot handle being called idiots and morons without getting their feelings hurt, then they have no business being on the line to start with. Like him or not, we voted him in. That IS his executive privilege to berate pretty much anyone he wants too. In conclusion, I'd go so far to speculate that those who go for his rope like an angry pit bull and DONT LET GO earn respect in mind that transcends any party affiliation. The man gets his kicks scrapping and playing rough. REAL bullies don't go near frothing, snarling pit bulls To that I say good for him!

French 9 years ago

" endless French-style squabbling over thinning slices of a shrinking pie. " Bien vu Monsieur Hanson, c´est une excellente description de la France.

Voyager 9 years ago

He will continue to tweet, because only someone so sure of his own rightness could so consistently tell the Washington swamp that it is so wrong, even when all hands of power are turned against him. If the swamp wins, I see no way to prevent the flood.

Walter Pazik 9 years ago

You wrote, "When George W. Bush’s popularity dipped below 30 percent in most polls, he at least could count on the money and support of the diehard Republican congressional delegations, the traditional big donors of the Republican party, the conservative media — National Review, Commentary, The Weekly Standard, the Wall Street Journal — grassroots local and state politicians, senior Republican statesman, and “wise men” retired politicians." Trump is breaking their rice bowls; this they can't abide. Trump's tweets are not for the swamp or the corrupt media or the corrupt political class; they are for us. The presidential swamp dwellers gave us an America on the precipice; Trump the rascal is removing us therefrom. We shall see in 2018.

Fred Hernandez 9 years ago

Very good.......very good. I only hope the President reads it.

NotPropagandized 9 years ago

OK, OK, already. My last mild rebuke of the exhortations against Trump tweets needs tweaking. Trump tweets are essential to keeping deservedly relentless pressure on the CorruptMedia I would now like to call the CriminalMedia. The is a role for Trump Tweets. So I'll modify my defense of Trump Tweets by saying Trump should carefully pick his Tweet Fights and leave the small stuff alone. . It would be nice, Dr. Victor Davis Hanson, for you to consider, analyze and find some way to propose that CollusiveOligopolistic CorruptMedia be challenged with new legislation recognizing the market power wielded by cooperating conniving media (remember JournoList?) and relegate the monopolists to Common Carrier status insisting that their content be generally available among themselves and other popular contributors. How to manage content decisions? Above my pay grade, but the collective collusion must be lassoed and brought to heel without offense to the 1st Amendment.

Christopher Sedlak 9 years ago

God bless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

james renew 9 years ago

Dr. Hanson's articulate and rational words always seem to calm my savage deplorable soul. Then President Trump Tweet slaps some puffy faced wrinkled swamp dweller, and I howl like the Werewolf in the full moon of Transylvania. I Have been a deplorable since he took the escalator down Trump Tower, and made a speech that won me over. Never figured he had a chance. But it did not take long to realize that he not only had the biggest set of stones in the room, but also the biggest brain. Looking back over my 64 years of life, sadly i have done things I would rather forget. Voting for George H.W. Bush, John McCain, and Mitt Romney will remain at the top.

Kerwin J Lebeis, MD 9 years ago

People say N. N. Taleb is an A**hole, who just happens to be right. Trump is an A**hole because he is fighting a two front war, against both Conservative Enablers and Progressive Totalitarians. The virtue of being an A**hole is its mostly nonverbal communication expressing loathing for these twin evils without giving them explicit verbal credit.

paul herriott 9 years ago

Fantastic writing....I am Canadian, lived in ManHattan, Chicago, LA...for over 30 years..love the US of A...but have never seen it as Fouled as it has been by the Bushes the Clintons, the Obamas...Literally "Rape of a Nation".....The sedition of the "lefties" is disgusting...they should all be garotted with piano wire and hung on meat hooks just as the Nazis did to their "Operation Valkyrie" Generals....The Nazis were swell to Rommel with a cap of strychnine....The US of A "Deep State"Traitors deserve such a fate. Your writing , your lecture on WW#2 was superb....I grew up through both Wars witnessed the Newsreel tests of the Atomic Bomb, the Japanese Destruction by the orders of "Give'em Hell Harry" You are 100% on POTUS...with thanks, Paul Herriott

Ann B Bassett Bienvenue 9 years ago

Hi Dr. Hanson, 2:15 EST December 19, 2017 The GOP seem to support his tax scam pretty well. There is still no CHIP funding. Our National Parks are being shrunk or opened to make room for oil drilling. Those are just 3 concerns off the top of my head that concern all of the "haters" and what the "fake news" is exposing. Admit it, his National Security Plan that was unveiled yesterday is a garbled mess of nationalism and ethnocentrism. When over 60+ percent of the American electorate are concerned about the FCC and Senators receiving financial incentives from donors, there is a problem and needs to be addressed. There is a looming government shutdown and Americans are anxious. There is no information, other than in social media, coming from our elected leaders. The White House press secretary is evasive in her answers to the press and occasionally lies outright to the White House Press Corps. Trump has shot himself in the foot one too many times. He has shown his true colors by defending Nazi's with torches yelling anti-semetic slogans and not once disavowing David Dukes's support. Anyone who disagrees with him is a liar or unpatriotic. I have had it with giving him a 3rd or 4th chance, and frankly find it surprising that you still defend him. Peace out, Boy Scout.