Archive

Is Kim Jong-un an Evil Buffoon or an Evil Genius?

Is Kim Jong-un an Evil Buffoon or an Evil Genius?

The Corner

The one and only.

by Victor Davis Hanson// National Review

 

Kim Jong-un has accomplished something that neither his grandfather nor father pulled off during the last 70 years: bringing an existential threat to the shores of the United States. North Korea’s handful of missiles that are soon to be pointed our way will be seen as posing a greater existential threat than do the far more numerous nuclear-tipped missiles of Russia and China — on the premise that by feigning (?) madness Kim is far more likely to use them. How weird that the really dangerous adversaries are seen as posing a far lesser danger than the far weaker one. Iran is looking at all this as a tutorial.

 

That fact alone has changed completely the strategic calculus of the Korean peninsula. Almost every decision that the U.S. will now make, as opposed to those of the last seven decades, will hinge on the premise that a nuclear nut can now threaten the lives of millions on the U.S. West Coast. Even in the age of North Korean technological incompetence and American high-tech excellence, a sophisticated society assumes it cannot live with the idea that there is a 1-2 percent chance that a lone North Korean nuclear missile — due to a supposedly insane finger on the button that claims it is indifferent to threats of U.S. massive retaliation — could at any moment actually get through U.S. defenses to reach Pacific Heights or South Central LA.

 

The result is that inevitably there will be a growing disconnect between South Korean and American strategic concerns, as our own policy will focus on the ramifications not just in terms of the sanctity of Seoul, but of the U.S. mainland. Such a shift in emphasis will be manipulated not just by North Korea but China as well as they insidiously remind South Korea that the U.S. is predicating its Korean strategy now solely in terms of its own self-interests. We should expect in the future lots of trial-balloon diplomacy from China suggesting U.S. troops vacate South Korea or a demilitarization of the peninsula, all predicated on the idea that Kim’s new gambit can be used to gain lots of concessions in the interest of “peace.”

 

How we came to this juncture is a tale of 30 years of bipartisan failure, or, to paraphrase Machiavelli, it is easier to cure a disease in its adolescence when its symptoms are harder to detect, but nearly impossible once there is no doubt about it pernicious presence.

 

Share This
VDH’s Blade of Perseus

About VDH’s Blade of Perseus

View Full Bio →

Discussion (6)

Join the conversation. Logged in subscribers avoid the Captcha verification and get priority commenting approvals. No vulgarity, links, or code allowed.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LK Shinneman 9 years ago

Just watched you on Tucker with Laura Ingram last night. You are REALLY good with your analysis on North Korea. I have a great idea. Let's air drop all kinds of propaganda, food, communication devices with our Satellites open the world to them by daily air drops of food and supplies that the government won't give them and say it is from your friends at the United Nations and the whole world is contributing. How much would it cost to bombard the country with stuff that would hurt the leadership and cause a change? Take his power over his people away and he will come to the table to negotiate or be replaced by his own people. That solution could lead to a united Korea as well. I have another idea that would save our world literally and would love to hear what you think about it? Give me a call. This is my cell LK Shinneman 317-946-5720 Thanks and keep up the good work...LK

Doug Mayfield 9 years ago

The really serious problem is not South Korea nor is it Kim himself. It's the incredible long term cowardice of America's elected officials who, if they think at all, seem to think that waiting, watching, hoping Kim will go away, and when he doesn't, then dithering helplessly, will all somehow solve the problem. The United States government must make it crystal clear that if a nuke from North Korea comes anywhere near America, that will be an act of war by both North Korea and China and we will immediately respond by vaporizing North Korea in its entirety as well nuking at least three military targets in China. China will then deal with Kim and the problem will disappear. Or we can wait for millions of American dead and watch the helpless grieving by our cowardly leaders in Washington. We'll see what happens.

Michael Davis 9 years ago

First, sincere thanks for all you do. Re: N Korea missiles, the biggest threat is not that one will hit LA. It's their soon likely ability to detonate a nuke high in the atmosphere, e.g., 100 miles or so, over the middle of the U.S. With an EMP attack, N Korea can put us back in the 18th century, instantaneously. This applies to any nation with the capability to make an EMP, attack, and it will take only one missile/nuke to do it. I believe that's the biggest existential threat to any modern nation on Earth.

Fred Taylor 9 years ago

I'm not sure I'm in 100% agreement with one part of your analysis: removal of US troops from the peninsula. They represent no strategic or even tactical threat but solely act as a tripwire for probably the least likely occurrence. What they do provide, to China, is a pinning down of U.S. forces that have to take strategic (and political) cognizance which allows China a freer hand in SE Asia and the S, China sea. What would be the benefit to China of us leaving? Your observation regarding Iran watching closely is very interesting as a gambit that they might play. We're prepared for armageddon and look forward to bringing about the arrival of the Hidden Imam. Hmmm!

Charles Tate 9 years ago

I fear there may be a major disconnect here in the strategic viewpoints between China and the U.S. China, being an ancient and cynical empire, likely thinks this sort of brinkmanship will force the U.S. to accept a humiliating diminishment of our role in the world, and that we will tolerate the domination of their lunatic proxy. But they seem not to grasp American tradition, as well as the emotionalism that drives democratic nations. Think Athens and Syracuse. The Chinese also seem to have a tin ear regarding nuclear diplomacy. It seems surprising to me that China would so invite a nuclear strike on North Korea. Strategically it seems the only response that makes sense. In conjunction with that we could support a South Korean attack to overrun the North. However, the nuclear attack should come first to prevent any unfortunate launches and to deter China from thinking it a possibility to again invade North Korea. Not since the Cuban crisis of 1961 have I seen a more probable chance that the U.S. will unleash a nuclear attack. I think it is almost an inevitability. The humanitarian fallout will be immense as the Nork regime is incinerated. All those starving people will need some help. This seems yet another reason why it is against our interest to antagonize the Russians. We could use their support.

Richard 9 years ago

So... evil buffoon or evil genius? Question begged.