Archive

Ideologues Make for Dangerous Politicians

Ideologues Make for Dangerous Politicians

Opportunists are at least attuned to public opinion, unlike ideologues.

By Victor Davis Hanson // National Review Online

 

Hillary Clinton is a seasoned liberal politician, but one with few core beliefs. Her positions on subjects such as gay marriage, free-trade agreements, the Keystone XL pipeline, the Iraq War, the Assad regime in Syria, and the use of the term “radical Islam” all seem to hinge on what she perceives 51 percent of the public to believe on any given day.

Such politicians believe truth is a relative construct. Things are deemed false by politicians only if they cannot convince the public that they are true — and vice versa. When the majority of Americans no longer believe Clinton’s yarns about her private e-mail server to the point of not wanting to vote for her, then she will change her narrative and create new, convenient truths to reflect the new consensus.

Donald Trump is an amateur politician but a politician nevertheless. He is ostensibly conservative, but he likewise seems to change his positions on a number of issues — from abortion to the Iraq War — depending on what he feels has become the majority position. And as with Clinton, Trump’s idea of truth is defined as what works, while falsity is simply any narrative that proved unusable.

Politicians glad-hand, pander, and kiss babies as they seek to become megaphones for majority opinions. But ideologues are different. They often brood and lecture that their utopian dreams are not shared by the supposedly less informed public.

To gain power, of course, ideologues can temporarily become political animals. Barack Obama ran in 2008 on popular positions such as reducing the national debt and opposing gay marriage and immigration amnesties, only to flip after he was re-elected and no longer needed to pander to perceived majority opinions.

But otherwise, Obama the ideologue seems to believe that big, redistributive government is always necessary to achieve a mandated equality of result — regardless of whether it ever works or should work in reality. He opposes a reduction in capital-gains tax rates even though he concedes that such cuts might bring in more revenue.

The administration has deemed the Affordable Care Act successful even though Obama’s assurances that it would lower deductibles and premiums, give patients greater choices, and ensure continuity in medical providers and plans have all proven to be untrue.

No matter: Obamacare fulfills the president’s preconceived notion that state-mandated health care is superior to what the private sector can provide.

Abroad, Obama starts from the premise that an overweening U.S. is not to be congratulated for saving the world in World War II, winning the Cold War, and ushering in globalization. Instead, its inherent unfairness to indigenous peoples, its opposition to revolutionary regimes and its supposed interventionist bullying disqualify it from being a moral and muscular leader of the world.

As a consequence of all this, facts often must be created to match pre-existing ideology.

A homophobic, radical Islamic terrorist in Orlando shouted “Allahu Akbar” as he mowed down the innocent in a gay nightclub. He called 9-1-1 to make sure the world knew that his killing spree was in service to the Islamic State. And in the midst of his murdering, he even called a local TV news station to brag on his jihadist martyrdom in progress. No matter. To Obama, who asserts that radical Islamic terrorism, which he refuses to identify in such terms, poses little threat (far less of a threat, he has said, than the dangers posed by accidental falls in bathtubs), the Orlando shooting was instead a symptom of a lack of gun control or endemic homophobia — anything other than what the killer himself said it was.

Guns, of course, had nothing to do with the 3,000 people killed on 9/11, with the Boston Marathon bombing, or with recent terrorist attacks in Oklahoma and at the University of California at Merced perpetrated by blade-wielding assailants. Tight restrictions on semi-automatic weapons could no more stop shootings in Europe than stop an epidemic of inner-city shootings in Chicago. No matter: The Orlando shooting must be ascribed to the availability of guns rather than to radical Islamic terrorism.

In both word and deed, Iran, Cuba, and Turkey are revolutionary societies in turmoil that have often voiced anti-Americanism. But to Obama, who at times has warmed up to all three, those regimes fit his deductive notion that America’s past behavior has earned it understandable antipathy from countries with legitimate grievances.

Bipartisan analyses agree that the withdrawal of all troops from Iraq in December 2011 threw away the victory obtained by the American surge of 2007, eroded the foundation of the nascent Iraqi democracy, and helped to birth and empower the Islamic State.

But to an ideologue such as Obama, the withdrawal simply reflected a universal truth that the U.S. must get out and leave the Middle East to its rightful owners — even if the president has been forced to send nearly 5,000 troops back into Iraq.

In general, politicians are rank opportunists, but at least most of them are malleable and attuned to public opinion.

But ideologues are far more anti-empirical — and thus dangerous.

Share This
VDH’s Blade of Perseus

About VDH’s Blade of Perseus

View Full Bio →

Discussion (12)

Join the conversation. Logged in subscribers avoid the Captcha verification and get priority commenting approvals. No vulgarity, links, or code allowed.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

DONALD LATHAM 10 years ago

I have just about heard enough of all the tv celebs pretending to be news reporters. every time some chaos happens they all promote there positions. they tell us that we must accept the new fangled morality because they just feel right . "we need some soul searching" they say All the soul searching gives us nothing, we don’t believe in things of the soul. We have counted building the soul as foolish, even stupid. So now the very wisdom that we seek from the souls of men, are gone. We have disassembled the soul, or dismissed it to the nether regions. There are no future plans for the souls future foundations. The proposition of the moralities that build have been replaced, by the age old sophistries that condemn us to a position void of choice. It will take the power of God to bring it back. That power is given to mankind who’s souls have been covenanted to the principle and laws that organize God’s kingdom here on earth. The convincing of men to the principles and ordinances that sustain the everlasting kingdom of God have been the responsibility of the faithful and obedient throughout the history of the earth. When humanity realizes it’s potential for greatness it is only through the application of the principles or laws that govern success and greatness, which are all found in the examples of Christ. Any deviation from his path is a repetitive lesson in futility. Christ’s examples aid in our search for soul, find Christ, find your soul. the repetition of change the successful outdated model speak , for the new and untried. it is backed up by the failed civilizations of time. that does not stop them, they usually dress it in a charming little ditty of if at first you dont succeed... johnny cochran would be proud. then they spin to the public tell us how great it is and if they get enough people they have a movement. then they move to the next phase of manipulating laws to protect it. now we have a modern day tower of babel because we don't know what are basic rights are, nor how we got them, even how to keep them. because as we have learned you have no rights unless they are special specific rights. and since we can't even figure out the basics, of what gender we are, the tower of special rights gets bigger. it is never ending. all at the expense of the people who have kept the very basic laws of morality, and the laws that protect those moralities. gone now to a popular government, "ever learning and never coming to a knowledge of the truth". cant wait to hear your take on the transgenered military. they pick on them the most because they hate them, and they have to remain silent on new commands.

Charles 10 years ago

That's only true (ideologues are anti-empirical) if their ideas/principles are irrationally subjectivistic and/or intrinsicistic (if that's a word) and result in the mass violation of the rights of individuals, as do the ideas and resulting policies of both "Liberals" and "Conservatives" these days. That's why everyone is so screwed up and there seems to be no "middle ground" for them to meet on. However, if one is an Objectivist, and his ideas are literally derived from and based upon empirically demonstrable objective reality (as is the philosophy of Objectivism as originated and described by Ayn Rand), then that would be the best and only good kind of "ideologue." If, that is, you are using that term to describe someone dedicated to certain principles to the exclusion of all others, not open to compromise or bargaining for political purposes. If you are using the term ideologue to refer to someone who is, by definition, NOT principled but is rather pragmatic and generally irrational, then there is no good ideologue. Until everyone learns that reality IS objective, and that individual rights are too, and that they are objectively knowable and definable, and are rationally justifiable and defensible, and are not open to negotiation or compromise, human beings will go on violating each others rights in the name of this or that subjective, non-objective, irrational cause or justification. Pretty much as we have been doing for our entire existence so far. The two most common justifications for the most horrible acts perpetrated by people are religion ("conservatives") and the "common" or "greater good" of society (the "liberals"). Both justifications are subjective and/or intrinsic, without objective/rational basis in reality. Both are, ultimately, simply used by manipulators to control other not-very-thoughtful people so that they can live off of them and treat them like cattle. And that will only go on to varying degrees until people come to understand that there is an objective code of morality that can be used to settle any and all conflicts between individuals. Quick, go read Ayn Rand, we are running out of time.

libra 10 years ago

Both Obama and the Clintons have become fabulously wealthy on the backs of ordinary hard working citizens. Both of these ideologues worship at the pedestals of greed, secrecy and political favor. Both should be grand juried, indicted and imprisoned for their corruption.

kenneth whitfield 10 years ago

The problem isn't that Hillary is an unethical, corrupt, lying criminal dirtbag. - Everyone knows that. The problem is that her supporters don't care.

Walter Pazik 10 years ago

Agreed that politicians are dangerous, and their threat is greater when they are uneducated: Obama and Hillary.

john jay 10 years ago

p.s. and, she is ruthless and dangerous in ways obama never dreamed, even with his islamic predilections. people die around her. early, very early.

john jay 10 years ago

sir: elect hilary, and she'll soon seem like the ideologue that she is. she'll say anything to be elected, she wail about the fate of the american middle class, but, elect her, and she will rule to the far left. the very far left. worse than obama. john jay

Johnd 10 years ago

Hillary Clinton is not just opportunistic but bears ALL the characteristics of a sociopath. Such a person will only ever have their own interests at heart.

Herb Clark 10 years ago

I think I'll run for King. This ain't working.

Thomas 10 years ago

It sounds as though, and you have convinced me, that for this country, there is really no hope.The American people are getting what they have voted for, and I think deserve the consequences. Example: the trashing of your property and community by illegal and legal Mexican immigrants. California, overwhelmingly voted Democrat and for Democratic US Senators and the Mexifornia legislature.

Camille Cazedessus 10 years ago

Being as well read and well traveled as you are, with with all due respect to you from a lowly 78 year old Graduate student, when you say "The Orlando shooting must be ascribed to the availability of guns rather than to radical Islamic terrorism" you, Dr. Hanson, are dead wrong. One can make a dangerous bomb by emptying the powder of several dozen shotgun shells or fire crackers, mix it up with a bunch of nails and bolts, stick a short fuse in it and set it off. The availability of radical Islamic (or any religion) terrorism has been with mankind for 100,000 years. If there is hate in ones heart, one can find a weapon in a candy store.

Chuck Rosenthal 10 years ago

Please wake me from this awful dream.