America Is More Fragile Than the Left Understands

Victor Davis Hanson
American Greatness

“There is a great deal of ruin in a nation.”
Adam Smith

The Left has been tempting fate since January 2021—applying its nihilist medicine to America on the premise that such a rich patient can ride out any toxic shock.

Our elites assume that all our nation’s past violent protests, all its would-be revolutions, all its cultural upheavals, all its institutionalized lawlessness were predicated on one central truth—America’s central core is so strong, so rich, and so resilient that it can withstand almost any assault.

So, we can afford 120 days in 2020 of mass rioting, $2 billion in damage, some 35 killed, and 1,500 police injured.

We can easily survive an Afghanistan, and our utter and complete military humiliation. There was no problem in abandoning some $70-80 billion in military loot to terrorists. Who cares that we tossed off a billion-dollar new embassy, and jettisoned a $300-million refitted air base, as long as our pride flags were waving in Kabul?

Certainly, we can afford to restructure all our universities, eliminate free expression and speech, and institute Maoist cultural revolutionary fervor in our revered institutions of higher learning—once the world’s greatest levers of scientific advancement and technological progress.

We can jettison merit in every endeavor, from banning the world’s great books to grading math tests to running chemistry experiments. And still, a resilient America won’t notice.

We assumed that our foundational documents—the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution—our natural bounty in North America, our cherished rule of law, our legal immigration traditions that drew in the most audacious and hardworking on the planet, and our guarantees of personal freedom and liberty led to such staggering wealth and affluence that nothing much that this mediocre generation could do would ever endanger our resilience.

But such inheritances are not written in stone. America, as the world’s only successful multiracial democratic republic, was always fragile. It was and is always one generation away from disappearing—should any cohort become so foolish as to mock its past, dismantle its institutions, revert to tribalism, redistribute rather than create wealth, and consume rather than invest.

We are that generation. And we have an accounting with nature’s limitations, given there is always a corrective, not a nice one, but remediation nonetheless for every excess.

Our major cities are no longer safe. Somehow, the Left has nearly wrecked San Francisco in less than a decade. A once beautiful and vibrant city is lawless, dirty, toxic, often boarded up, and losing population. It has turned into a medieval keep of well-protected knights in secure fiefs while everyone else is engaged in a bellum omnium contra omnes.

We know it is so because California public officials talk of anything and everything—Roe v. Wade, transitions to electric cars, hundreds of millions of dollars in COVID-19 relief for illegal aliens—to mask their utter impotence to address feces in the street, the random assaults on the vulnerable, and the inability to park a car and return to it intact.

Ditto the Dodge City downtowns of Chicago, Los Angeles, New York, Seattle, Baltimore, Washington, and a host of others. In just four or five years, they have given up on fully funding the police, aggressive prosecutors indicting the violent, and ubiquitous civil servants ensuring the streets are free of trash, vermin, flotsam, jetsam, and human excrement.

There are natural reactions to such excess. The most terrifying is that our once-great cities, especially their downtowns, will simply shrink into something like ghost towns—our versions of an out-West Bodie, or an abandoned Roman city in the sand like Leptis Magna, or a Chernobyl.

But the culprit will not be a played-out mine, or encroaching desert, or a nuclear meltdown, but the progressive leadership of a worn-out, bankrupt people who no longer possess the confidence to keep their urban civilization safe and viable. And so, they either fled, or joined the mob, or locked themselves up in fortified citadels, both in fear to go out and terrified of losing what they owned.

We are seeing that deterioration already in our major cities. Stores are boarded up. Women cease to walk alone after sunset. Police officers walking the beat are now rare. Hate crimes, smash-and-grab robberies, and carjackings go unpunished. Streets are filthy and littered. Commerce and human interaction cease at dusk, as if in expectation that zombies will emerge to control the streets. Criminals when arrested are not always identified—the media censoring names and descriptions on their own selective theories of social justice.

But again, the culprit is not the COVID plague or want of money. It is us, we who turned over our cities to the incompetent, the selfish, the timid, and the violent.

There is again an antidote. But doubling the police force, bringing back broken-windows policing, electing tough prosecutors, moving the homeless from the downtown into hospitals and supervised shelters beyond the suburbs, arresting, convicting, and incarcerating the guilty—all that seems well beyond this generation’s capacity.

Would not such efforts be unfair to the mere rock-thrower? Who says the fentanyl user has no right to defecate on the street? Would not our jails become overcrowded? Would the incarcerated be unduly overrepresented by this or that group?

Joe Biden took a strong economy—albeit one that after three serial spendthrift presidencies faced huge national debt and a rendezvous with fiscal sobriety—and has utterly ruined it.

He discouraged labor participation with federal checks. He ensured that his minions on the politicized Federal Reserve Board would keep interest rates artificially low. Biden inflated the money supply while debasing the value of the currency. He brought back mindless regulation and put ideological commissars in place to ensure the corporations, banks, and Wall Street would be woke, allowing ideology to warp ancient economic laws that kept prices stable, supply and demand in balance, and incentives to work and profit.

Many thought Biden would have needed at least four or five years to wreck such a strong economy with such nihilism rather than a mere 16 months.

Yet nature is about to step in with a recession and perhaps even a depression to correct the Biden madness. If interest rates rise, capital dries up, businesses close, employers cut back, consumers no longer have access to easy money, and the nation becomes inert, then the country will be worse off, spend less—and that too will be a brutal solution of sorts to Biden’s hyperinflation and stagflation.

Still, it is hard to see how anyone in the government might prefer the proper and necessary medicine at this late hour. An updated Simpson-Bowles plan still could address long-term insolvency. Meaningless regulations could be pruned back. The tax code could be radically altered and simplified to encourage investment rather than consumption. Entitlements could be calibrated by incentives to become productive rather than to remain inert. All of that might return us to a sound currency, a strong GDP, long-term financial solvency, and general prosperity for all. But are not such medicines perceived as worse than the disease?

There is an answer to the open border, when upwards of 4 million illegal aliens will flow into the United States in a mere two years, for the most part without audits, English, capital, income, and vaccinations—and with no idea how to house, feed, or provide health care for millions without background checks.

At this late date, the corrections of stopping catch and release, ending amnesties, hiring more border patrol officers and immigration judges, or building more detention centers are too little too late.

Eventually, Americans will become acculturated to large enclaves of endemic poverty, as millions with no familiarity with the United States are neither assimilated nor integrated.

The border will then disappear, and northern Mexico and the southern United States will become indistinguishable, as millions simply drift back and forth in the manner of an ancient Gaul or Germania. Large areas of Texas, Arizona, and California are already returning to such pre-state status.

Or the alternate corrective will be the completion of a massive wall from the Pacific to the Gulf, with strict audits of all would-be immigrants, immediate deportations for lawbreakers, and legal only immigration that is measured, diverse, and meritocratic.

We are reaching the inflection point quickly and will either experience the absolute destruction of the border or a radical backlash, given that the current mess is unsustainable. Either a nation with borders survives or a tribal and nomadic region supplants it.

If America chooses to shut down refineries, put our rich oil and natural gas fields off-limits, cancel pipelines, and demonize the fossil fuel industry, then, of course, prices for carbon fuels will explode.

The Biden Administration talks nonsensically about Teslas, batteries, and electric replacements. But it is not greenlighting mining for the critical minerals needed for batteries. It is not encouraging nuclear power plants to provide enough power for a clean fleet of 200 million electric cars. There is no Marshall Plan to wean America off mostly non-polluting natural gas and gasoline onto electricity-hungry engines.

Instead, Biden begs the Saudis, the Russians, the Venezuelans, and even the Iranians to pump the fuel he will not. He seeks to drain the Strategic Petroleum Reserve that can supply only a fraction of the oil America gulps daily. He defines his own pre-midterm, self-created mess as a national emergency to tap a reserve he could never fill or refill.

So, what is the natural corrective to unaffordable fuel?

A likely Biden recession or depression, in which the middle classes simply do not enjoy jobs that pay enough to afford $6-9-a-gallon gas. And so, they will not drive. Vacations, optional shopping trips, and visits to friends—all that and more will taper off. Gas will stabilize at near-European levels, and the people, as planned, will be rerouted into dirty and unsafe subways and mass transit.

Biden will be happy. But America won’t be the same mobile country.

America’s bounty was predicated on each generation following the prompt of the prior, modulating when change was necessary, but not daring to tamper with the foundational principles and values that explained our singular wealth, power, and leisure.

This generation in its arrogance tested fate. It felt itself smarter and morally superior to its betters of the past. It lost that wager and now we the public are paying for its foolishness. To destroy America as we have always known it, there was far less necessary to ruin than our elite believed.

Like a stunned adolescent whose reckless incompetence totaled the family car, the Left seems shocked that America proved so fragile after all.

Share This

22 thoughts on “America Is More Fragile Than the Left Understands”

  1. The left didn’t ever contemplate the right would fight back to the extent we are seeing.

    Starving the beast ( the half dozen or so major urban areas that the left ( sorry no upper case) controls pretty well everything from) by not resupplying them with food, it wouldn’t take more than 2 weeks to get their attention.

  2. Let’s see: Dems rigging the ballots (Nazi intimidation to force majority in Reichstag), Jan. 6 (Burning the Reichstag), announcement of Mandatory Vaccinations (Krysalnacht), Force teaching of Woke policy in Public Schools (Aryan Race theories taught in Grundeschule), Woke commercials (Goebbels Media Propaganda), Blaming inflation on the Russians (Blaming inflation on the Soviets). And all this can be swept away on Nov. 2nd 2022? God bless us all, it’s just not going to be that easy.

    1. Yes, it very well may be easy: the sane people naturally gravitate to the common notions of magnanimity and of not hitting the fallen enemy, and that is why (among other things) Republicans never use their majority to the fullest.
      This time (and I will be pestering both of my senators), once we have taken the Congress, we MUST eliminate the root causes of this calamity, and do it resolutely, without mercy, and without compassion to the enemy. Yes, they are enemies. Start impeachment against both POTUS and VP, start investigations of everything and anything.

      1. Deplorable Joe

        All Congressional committees will become Oversight Committees. We must expel Neo Marxism from our Representative Republic. In other words, we stop electing people who despise America.

    2. You’re right. However, no one can convince me that the goal of the marxist left in this country is anything shy of complete and total obliteration of this republic.

      Frankly, my wife and I are most of the way to making the decision to leave the U.S.

        1. Antigua. English speaking, higher literacy rate than the US and a killer exchange rate.
          Oh, and a “beach for every day of the year).

        1. You’re right, the U.S. has potential, potential unfortunately no longer realized. We have 2, arguably 3 generations that are ignorant, amoral and highly emotional that have led us to the state of near collapse we find our country in. As I’ve mentioned previously, we have a population that votes for the man and not his policies amongst other symptoms of societal rot.
          We’re fed up with it.

        1. Antigua, thank you for asking. Please see my comments further up the thread. Add to my previous comments, low crime, and a chill and moral people

    3. dont worry its a cakewalk via masyers cakeshop 10 yr ordeal.jack is in for aGOOD SURPRISE AT LAST.biggest boom ever seen count on it

  3. I’m a Canadian but I love the USA and the freedom it stands for to the rest of the world’s inhabitants. Notice I didn’t other governments! However you appear to be heading towards civil war. The Dems & media lies about everything and the right is not cohesive enough to counter balance. Get with it America, Canada is the buffer zone between Russia, China and the nuclear threat. My advice since your probably not asking, get tough and throw the weasels out of office and clean house. Easy to be a communist when you’re already rich or work for the government.

    1. Seems to me Canada has already capitulated almost completely to woke nutjobs in their government and the rest of their country. The minority seem sensible but Is it enough to make a change? Not so sure. America will be the world’s savior again. It’s frankly exhausting!

  4. William Hardwick

    Let’s get the House & Senate and bring them all to their knees they have made it clear they are not fond of taking one unless it’s for a National Anthem.
    They stand Against Everything America Is For!
    Time to Napalm the Fringe!

  5. Allison Williams

    This is a brilliant summation. We all see it. All the people we are about to elect have no cohesive vision to get ahead of the calamity that’s coming. They stick to the talking points and settle into hearings and delay. I want action!!! Biden has his veto pen. We need a plan to face our enemy of tyranny head on. So little time.

    I hope VDH will guide the way

  6. Charles M Romer

    Ahh. The miracle that awaits in November! Keep chattering guys. That’s the way to jinx the whole deal. 2020 was actually our last chance and we blew it.

    Where we all go? The way of all flesh.

    Millennia from now when the descendents of the survivors study the ruins I hope that they will find Hanson’s work squirreled away in some forgotten monastery and take heed.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *