Archive

08-13-2018 Angry Reader

08-13-2018 Angry Reader

From An Angry Reader:

Subject: You are a racist idiot

Your articles and ideas lower the IQ of this country every time they are published. The racism you employ in articles about Black Lives Matter, Crime, and pretty much anything you write is so disgusting its hard to swallow. Truly die in a hole.

—————————————————————

Dear Quite, Quite Angry Reader Levi Kimmel,

You score impressively high on our Angry Reader unhinged scale: the personal insult (check), the unfounded accusations (check), the lack of a single fact or supporting element of evidence (check), and the expected threat at the end (check). I’d give your letter an 8 of 10 (the all CAPs, obscenity, grammatical incoherence, and serial exclamation marks were absent).

As to your charges, explain how I lower the IQ of the country. Do you mean people read columns and lose computing or comprehension capacity? Are you drawing on some sort of new neurophysiological research?

I have hardly written at all about “crime” or Black Lives Matter; and when I have it is to note the tragic spiral that we find ourselves in with inordinate per capita black crime creating stereotypes which in turn manifest in increased vigilance concerning inner-city black male youth, which in turn is seen as scapegoating and profiling, which in turn further poisons race relations. Our mutual goal should be to create viable job opportunities in the inner city, offer better vocational training, close the border to offer African-Americans more leverage with employers, and to focus on arresting hardened gang member criminals who make life for others so dangerous. As for Black Lives Matter, I object to any tribal chauvinism whether La Raza (“the race”) or any “white” affiliated group. All lives of course matter equally, and there is no such thing as “the race” that is innately superior to any other.

Finally, we all die, and half us will in truth end up in some sort of “hole,” so I don’t quite follow your final threat. Do you mean at 65 that I should prematurely die now rather than naturally in just a few years?

Why are progressives and liberals so full of hatred and venom? Is it a psychological sort of squaring the circle? Are their natural furor and frustrations projected onto others, as they adopt cosmic for-show liberal pieties to mitigate the elemental anger that drives them to issue threats like your own?

Victor Hanson

Share This
VDH’s Blade of Perseus

About VDH’s Blade of Perseus

View Full Bio →

Discussion (34)

Join the conversation. Logged in subscribers avoid the Captcha verification and get priority commenting approvals. No vulgarity, links, or code allowed.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Luisa Vanco 8 years ago

Well, this angry reader has certainly articulated his state of mind, well, articulately.

dan gremillon 8 years ago

Perhaps this rancorous Kimmel should apply to replace the "famous" Jimmy Kimmel on TV. Or maybe just be a stand in. Both like-minded idiots and one of the reasons this country is going to hell

Theodore Branin, Esq 8 years ago

Professor Hanson is my North Star. He is the only light in this murky period of our history.

Ted Branin 8 years ago

Dr. Hanson! You are the only bright light in our murky culture. I have followed you for years and read most of your books. Keep healthy! We need you.

George Miller 8 years ago

Nice response, Prof. I admire your restrain and precison rebuttal.

Eric Hancock 8 years ago

“... inordinate per capita black crime creating stereotypes which in turn manifest in increased vigilance concerning inner-city black male youth, which in turn is seen as scapegoating and profiling, which in turn further poisons race relation...” This sentence is a stereotype itself: a common white bugaboo that poisons the white end of race relations (the only end that is poisoned) and reveals that you do see race as all explaining. Say, rather, that poverty creates a desperation conducive to “inordinate per capitalism crime.” The you’ll have a grasp of causative factors of crime that isn’t race based. Now, of course, you may well soon face the question of why people of color are so grossly over represented among those counted as poor. But the answer to that involves white political power. I wonder if you have the capacity to articulate change for white political power? Just asking... albeit with generalized scepticisn. Having generally scanned your doin any themes, so called.

Charles Tate 8 years ago

I sure hope you live a lot longer, and in good health, than just a few years.

Jerome D Boyle 8 years ago

VDH, Was the e-mail flecked with slobber? It DOES sound like he was foaming at the mouth.

M Montgomery 8 years ago

Amazing. Hard to figure how anyone could find you racist. Times are seriously warped. Up is down and good is bad. Depressing.

Edward Smith 8 years ago

I noticed another similarly odd post on one of your YouTube podcasts (audio only) where the person accused you of being anti-Trump and Left wing, when you spent most of your talk supporting or at least understanding what he is doing and why he was elected. Is it something in the water?

Debrah 8 years ago

["Are their natural furor and frustrations projected onto others, as they adopt cosmic for-show liberal pieties to mitigate the elemental anger that drives them to issue threats like your own?"] Simply stellar. However, one wonders. Why would you expect to die naturally in "just a few years" if you're only 65?

John Fiorentine 8 years ago

Doctor surely you know that though all animals are equal, some animals are more equal than others. We coastal elites didn’t become elites for shits and giggles. Sort of defeats the purpose of being elite if we aren’t more equal.

Michael D Zorn 8 years ago

I'm trying to decide whether the mind-set that inclines toward unchecked anger, toward disdain for other opinions, tends toward Progressivism, or whether Progressivism instills those attitudes into the True Believer.

Walt Kisner 8 years ago

That has to be a rewarding and revealing comment. Please, keep up the great work.

Victor Hansen 8 years ago

Hate flows from left to right, and degenerates into name-calling when reason fails.

Tim Warburton 8 years ago

"Why are progressives and liberals so full of hatred and venom? Is it a psychological sort of squaring the circle? Are their natural furor and frustrations projected onto others, as they adopt cosmic for-show liberal pieties to mitigate the elemental anger that drives them to issue threats like your own?" May I be so bold as to suggest a couple of gentle modifiers? "Why are SOME progressives and liberals so full of hatred and venom? Is it a psychological sort of squaring the circle? Are their UNnatural furor and frustrations projected onto others, as they adopt cosmic for-show liberal pieties to mitigate the CHILDISH elemental anger that drives them to issue RANCOROUS AND HATRED FILLED threats like your own?" PLEASE EXPLAIN HOW YOUR LETTER ENHANCES SUCH PROGRESSIVE NOTIONS AS LOVE AND CARING FOR ALL FELLOW MEN? WOULD IT NOT BE YOUR TASK TO BRING THE LIGHT TO MY EYES SO THAT I COULD SEE THE ERROR OF MY WAYS? I am almost gagging now.

Darrell 8 years ago

The person who wrote this is clearly unsuited for a country that has a constitution that guarantees the right to freedom of thought and speech. This person prefers only one view should rule over all of them and death to those who disagree with their point of view. Now that...is really a good example of a high IQ. I am sure all the high IQ scientists that fled Germany prior to WWII would have fled in deep regret that the monolithic Nazi mindset which was full of venom towards those who disagreed was exactly the one they hoped to bring to America and to see it flower and bloom as we see now today with all of its glorious irony. Yes, they must have landed on American soil and thought- "Freedom to think and speak without a firing squad? What a low IQ proposition!!" Perhaps this Angry Reader is angry because they lack the courage to move to a country that agrees with them that ONLY ONE VIEW SHOULD RULE THEM ALL !!!

Robert Port 8 years ago

Victor; Meet my many local friends at our McDonalds when I have time for coffee and a sandwich. The 2 for $4.00 deal is a bargain as I pay fifty cents more for the 2nd sandwich and give the nearly free sandwich to one of my many new friends. They aren't healthy so eating two isn't good business. My concern is that many of these interesting and good people I've made friends with have a political mindset that is 180 degrees different from mine. How can two people look at the same data and get two very different messages? I'm not extremely bright but my reasoning skills are working quite well. How can one politely say : Other than us sending Trump to charm school I can't see what else can be improved. I suspect that their fear of rocking the boat is the real issue with my fellow Americans... Hopefull the media will soon learn that Mr Trump loves a good fight and has a ego that demands results regardless of punishment delivered via the nay sayers................. Bob

Arnold Bottoms 8 years ago

VDH, I do hope you continue responding to angry readers. Thank you for your wisdom and wit.

Lee Fisher 8 years ago

A perfect response on your part. The obvious here however, is that you are in a battle of wits with an unarmed person. thank you so much for your great insight into what's going on in the country. As fortunate as we are to have Trump and no Hillary we should be on our knees daily thanking God . Being born in the United States is like winning the lottery

Scott Bevan 8 years ago

I love it when you take apart moronic Angry Readers like the most recent. It elevates my IQ

Tom Bright 8 years ago

Hanson may not get it, but suddenly I, if no other, do. I feel so guilty.

Bill Jeans 8 years ago

Sir; They are so full of vitriol and hate because that is all that is left to them since their arguments are bereft of logic, accuracy or truth. No charge for the information as I suspect you are as aware of it as I am.

Kay Martin 8 years ago

Brilliant reply, as always.

Constancio S Asumen Jr 8 years ago

The main reason progressives and liberals are so unhinged, full of hatred and venom is their failure to retrofit the external manifestations of the world surrounding them into the rigid template of their perception. Ergo they throw a temper tantrum much like a three-year-old who does not observe his cereal meld into the forage he expected to eat, yell and scream at the unsuspecting mother. One of the hallmark maladjustment of a liberal progressive is the incapacity to re-calibrate the template of reality at his disposal.

Brian Modell 8 years ago

Dr. Hanson, To suggest that one can lower another's IQ with anything short of a lobotomy underscores the sub-triple digit IQ of the one making such a claim. , You are one of the most concise and brilliant speakers on all matters of historical context. You challenge me to do my own research before staking out a position in virtually any dialog with family and friends, and I now search for multiple examples to secure my claims thus engaging the thoughts of others. The notion of your mind being silenced by anything other than natural causes is no less tragic, in my humble opinion, than natures own silencing of Dr Krauthammer. I eagerly await every "Private Papers" email and "Classicist Podcast". Your historical skill-set is as essential in navigating the social dangers ahead as my multi-scan radar is in navigating the threat of thunderstorms while aloft. Thank you for sharing all that you have learned.

Roy Belluz 8 years ago

Victor, You are the voice of reason in the middle of this countries storm! I love reading your articles and seeing you on TV. Keep up the good work and information. The silent majority is listening.

C. 8 years ago

This letter writer is truly a low info person and decredits himself with this attack. Cannot place any validity in his opinion. Professor Hanson is precise and clear in his thinking and writing. I look forward to his column, find them interesting, informative and well thought out. Not only is the man intellectual and precise, but he writes and speaks at common denominator level rather than talk down to me. I appreciate, respect and learn from his talks and columns whether topic is local or federal governmen policy, economics, security, bureaucracy or ancient armies and battles, empires and rulers or his personal experiences as a farmer or academician. Carry on Professor Hanson.

Brian Franklin 8 years ago

Greetings, The racial baiting and victim stories are really getting old. Angry reader, get some workboots and a lunchpail Nothing is stopping you from starting your own business in your own community where you can feel safe from the racists. Dr. Hanson, in regards to one of your recent articles about the U.S., has never been imperialists I would bet that General Smedley Butler would disagree. BTW, no one in my town is an imperialist or would ever condone imperialism. Must be a D.C. and Wall Street thing and not a general movement of the people of these states. There should be a very clear distinction here. I know that no one in our town had a beef with anyone in any town in Vietnam. Fighting for freedom everywhere. A nice tall glass of Kool-Aid that is. "Truth, Justice, and the American way." Too much TV. Merit-based immigration requirements? Who decides who has merit? I was a CIT employee where CIT sponsored Green Cards. CIT backed some poor horses because those making the selections were themselves underqualified. Poor scientists float into management positions and they don't hire people who are smarter than they are if they can help it. The VA hires foreign doctors who are painfully underqualified. The VA administration is completely incapable of making merit-based selections besides that by hiring foreign doctors over homegrown squeezes out the homegrown doctors and leaves them with oppressive college debt. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-india-medicine-education-specialrepor/special-report-why-indias-medical-schools-are-plagued-with-fraud-idUSKBN0OW1NM20150617 One more thing. There are some interesting diary notes Patton wrote which should still be boxed up in the basement of his home in San Marino, CA. He dwells on his reincarnation from great generals from the past. An especially interesting entry about the "comfort" afforded ranking officers during their campaigns.

Mark E Dapier 8 years ago

Very well reasoned, well stated and classy response. Way to go

Phil Smith 8 years ago

Excellent commentary by you Mr. Hanson and an excellent reply as well. I myself actually find the liberal/progressive herd of snowflakes highly entertaining. They remind me of mad dogs that are so pissed off that they bark and growl while chasing their own tail around trying to bite it. I must admit I do my very very best to get'em pissed the hell off for the entertainment value. I'm a Southern Born N Bred Conservative USMC VET who doesn't give a rat's ass what a liberal/progressive spews from their bacteria filled pie hole. Period. Have a nice day. Phil

Martin Capages Jr, 8 years ago

Dr. Hanson: Well said. But you can’t “understand it for him”. Great rebuttal. Maybe he should try one of your classes. Martin.

Richard 8 years ago

Let's see, there's Jimmy Kimmel and now there's Levi Kimmel. Might one be safe in concluding that those with the last name Kimmel are myopic, simplistic and quite likely anencephalic? Probably not but I'm going to stick with the assumption, nonetheless.

David Schortner 8 years ago

Mr. Hanson........I am a "racist". I'm so tired of people. I'm embarrassed and ashamed to be part of the "human race". Humans are the most treacherous species on the planet. . Yeah, I'm a racist.