From An Angry Reader:
Your article…about NATOs challenge is Germany, not America.
Sir,
With all respect but before you write any article you should learn about history. Germany did not start both World Wars. You might want to do some research before writing anything. Very sad how little people here actually know about history and then write about it in an article.
—————————————————————————
Dear Angry Reader Susanna Mackenzie,
It is a silly tactic to accuse someone, as compensation for one’s own abject ignorance of history that you display in your letter. I wrote an entire book on World War II, and many as well on European history. That constitutes “some research.” In World War I, the German Schlieffen Plan and the Kurt Riezler’s Septemberprogramm were reflective of Germany’s prewar and wartime ambitions to expand its power in Europe beyond its borders, in a way not so true of its prime antagonists, France and Britain. I suggest you read carefully the terms of the indemnities and land confiscations of 1871 that ended the Franco-Prussian war; the aims of the Septemberprogramm, the particulars of the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk of 1918, and the program of aggression outlined in the 1920s in both Hitler’s Mein Kampf and The Second Book. If you would do so, you would learn of a pattern of German aggression and territorial expansion and acquisition over some 70 years, that ceased only with catastrophic defeat in 1945, the appearance of NATO, the nuclear status of Britain and France, the common enemy of the Soviet Union and the 50-year Cold War, and the utopian attempts of a pan-continental EU. Yet nonetheless Germany finds itself at odds with Southern Europe, Eastern Europe, Britain, and the US, and there is a common denominator: a sort of demand to shape up to German norms of financial protocols, of open borders, of a tough British departure from the EU, and of a reluctance to meet its NATO promises—while running up the world’s largest account surplus and a $65 billion trade surplus with the U.S., both of which Germany insists are non-negotiable realities.
Victor Davis Hanson
Discussion (34)
Join the conversation. Logged in subscribers avoid the Captcha verification and get priority commenting approvals. No vulgarity, links, or code allowed.
germany is now a janky hoopty thanks to frau merkel
It must be tiring, dealing so often, with the willfully ignorant. Thank you for setting the record straight, for yet another lost soul.
Dear Victor, You might have added a study of Lord Keynes' "The Economic Consequences of the Peace" to your response to yet another historical ignoramus. Not only does the great Lord point out the problems with the Versailles settlement, but he also explores Germany's mercantilist obsessions from the beginnings of the Second Reich. Keynes notes that within 30 years Germany had become the largest trading partner of the major powers at the time, again running large current account surpluses. It's incredibly sad that after all this time - and even after Keynes brilliant idea of the Bancor at Bretton Woods, to ameliorate the worst excesses of aggressively mercantilist nations - we appear to have learned precisely nothing. President Trump is to be commended for finally grasping the nettle, finally cutting the Gordian know on world trade that the pathetic liberal elite dare not confront. Best Ian
In Kinston ..its a river of history here. The music's good ,..we're all on the net. And the department of agriculture is about to swing into action to save Ronald Reagan,! Again
And so another Angry Reader has been laid to rest!! Go Victor Davis Hanson! You Rock!
I very much appreciate your thoughtful and well-informed essays. When I disagree w/your analysis, which is rare, you challenge me to argue in the same way you do--which is not only enjoyable but refreshing.
Yeah, sure.... But Prof Hanson, what if you are wrong? WWI, WWII, Illuminati. (?) A lot of capitol "I"s there. Coincidence ?
Amazing how someone starts out with the phrase "with all respect" and turns to show nothing but contempt. In this case the angry reader also displays an incredible lack of knowledge. I suppose angry reader has self-limited to 140 characters at a read,,, for the past decade.
Excellent historical backhand.
Nice Angry Reader response Vic! Use the big hammer. Thats what I say. lol
Dear Prof. Hanson, dear not-really-angry-reader Susanna Mackenzie. The critic of Germany not opening both wars is not as far fetched as the valued teacher holds it. Germany's role in originating WW1 is different, and far from being the main culprit. Even though VDH's acclamation of Germany being aggressive is undeniable, read Fritz Fischer - 'Griff nach der Weltmacht' - but it was not only party aggressive and the others not sacrificial lambs, remaining passive until the sabre rattling militaristic Kaiser attacked them. France, in denying Germany a place at the table in both Moroccan crisis's, successfully ostracized Germany, but came to terms with every other power. And none of the arguments from the respected teacher covers the situation in July 1914. How could a hard peace treaty for Russia 1917 have been a reason for the emergence of a conflict three years earlier. And the respected teacher claims of Germany holding french territories - after it had declared war on Germany 1870 and lost them - but closes his eyes for the French having a strong motive for a revenge war. And Russia with its unstable aristocratic system, seeking external stabilization by war after the losses against Japan - as well a long established motive for war, see the Falkland war 1982. Russia's aggression - backed up by France's intention to use the Sarajevo incident as a tripwire for a for a long prepared war with Imperial Germany, with a strong competitor for Frances demand of being the hegemon over central Europe (read Graham Allison), so Russia came to backing up a Serbian government, which had engaged in an actual Balkan war 1912, both denied Austria-Hungary an active role in the investigation of the murders in Sarajevo. Transfer this situation to September 2001 and imagine a blockade of US-investigations by a foreign power - unimaginable, and surely a reason for a military conflict, or not ..? But in the 1914 case of state sponsored terror by Serbia – that killed an unpopular but not belligerent heir apparent - such demands are unjust? A revanchistic, belligerent France and Russia converted a grave diplomatic crisis, maybe of a contained war between two neighboring states, into a European conflagration. Read Christopher Clark - Sleepwalkers, or listen to his his lecture about France and its role in regarding die Origins of the Great war - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dx_V4NAUuW8 . Germany backed his ally Austria-Hungary, the famous 'blanc cheque' and this it is part - ónly - of the ‚guilt‘. There was no active seeking of conflict by Germany until it became unavoidable. So - the main responsibility for WW1 lies on others shoulders, and the same for the upcoming of the monsters, Hitler and Lenin/ Stalin. This you recognized correct Susanne, sry respected teacher for the objection.
Susanna ... Didn't your mother tell you that "poking" a lion is not a good idea. Your ignorance of history is common ... why not make an effort to learn. I suggest reading Professor Hanson's books to start.
Love your book about "The Second World Wars".........last I counted there were close to 700 pages of research/text. Maybe the angry reader wanted 800 pages instead.
An excellent summary. The other problem country is Russia, shed of its Soviet Union but wanting it back. But, the hurdle of a small no growth one product economy is too high.
To paraphrase the lyrics of Cher (written by Sonny Bono)..."Bang, Bang you shot that baby down"
Game, set, and match to Dr. Hanson. :-)
Bravo Victor, It appears Ms Mackenzie is a woman those doesn’t let facts and history get in the way of her perception of history. Thank you, F. Michael Sharp Jr mbs626@verizon.net
That was a MOAB.
Something written a week ago; obviously more opinion than historical fact, but still not far from your understanding. At least in my opinion. Why NATO Matters freebeacon.com A strong NATO helps ensure the young Men & Women of North America are not pressured into fighting yet another European War. I am able to give evidence just how quickly the French Citizen forgets the sacrifice of North America. BUT; the value of everything is also dependent upon the support made by all in any Organization. -- If the German People continue to only be interested in Themselves, as in past Generations; then welcome back to the Anglo-American influence for an Enlightenment Civilization and let the self-absorbed French wallow in Their "suck-up" to Germany once again. Move quickly Poland; Holland; Denmark; Norway; Estonia; Lithuania; Latvia; to Come Aboard the Anglo-American & other Enlightenment Countries.-- Ignore Sweden & Finland they have never considered anything except their own self-interest.
Dr. Hanson, I almost feel sorry for the ignorant fool who challenged your knowledge of History... You definitely took him to school. Thank you for all the brilliant insight in your writings. I always learn something new when I sit under your teachings. Ken O'Connell
We said Dr. Hanson.
Appears to be a closet Holocaust Denier! His statement is on a par with those ideas!
Simple thought: German reunification should not have been allowed. Tolerating it was as much a product of our own "cookie monster" approach to the situation following the dissolution of the Soviet Union as it was of German ambition. Also, a clear violation of the Helsinki Accord. Come to think of it, is some form of German deunification out of the question? For pete's sake, and "pete" isn't the word I would use on the streetcorner, they were the biggest loser in the biggest war. I learned something about history even at my Tier III (now Tier IV in the new university caste system) college. An important element of geopolitical theory is the difference between "big" and "little" national outlooks, in Germany's case, the grossdeutsch and kleindeutsch concepts, the former based on landpower and latter based on a Western outlook and trade. After the more extreme idea for what to do with Germany, such as the Morgenthau Plan, failed, the victorious powers settle on the kelindeutsch concept as acceptable. The Soviet Union implicitly accepted this all along, and the concept was formalized in Helsinki. The great existential hazard, we were told, lied in the attempt to pursue both concepts at once, which is what Germany is doing right now. This is issue applies to America and China as well. China is in the coils of the hazards inherent in pursing both concepts at one. Under Trump, America is moving back in the direction of "big" America, a basic world policy which put the development of America first. If any of the minority blocks break away even partially from the Popular Frontism-lite of the Democratic Party, it's all over.
You are too kind in your response. Sometimes a bad child needs the switch.
Brilliant response, brilliant historian, brilliant scholar. There’s only one VDH, unfortunately.
The angry reader claims that Germany did not start both World Wars but fails to identify who they believe started the wars and fails to provide any evidence to support this assertion other than to claim that Dr. Hanson did not complete research on the subject. Not only was the writer short on details but Dr. Hanson was able to refute them all including the charge of not researching the topic. If the reader has such documentation or sources to refute Dr. Hanson, I would be curious to see them The letter rings hollow when no evidence is provided to support the assertions that were made. The predominate groups attempting to support this case tend to involve themselves in or support German Nationalists looking to push all blame onto Austria/Hungary, those sympathetic or supportive of the Nazis or their modern fan base, and those actively supporting conspiracies involving Jewish business or banking interests (anti Israel, anti Jewish, anti Zionist acolytes, etc.).
This particular individual is not an aberration. This is the foundation I why people like myself are increasingly pessimistic for the future. There are simply too many self reinforcing societal pathologies. As precise an anology that exists in the physical world is the term aerodynamic flutter. It is the description of what makes a flag wave. On an aircraft, it is what you notice about the ailerons just before your wing is ripped from it’s weakest point in the structure.
For Suzanna Mackenzie, Prove that YOUR facts are true, hon. All standard World War II Histories begin with the premise that the GERMAN AGGRESSION AGAINST POLAND ON SEPTEMBER 1, 1939 initiated the conflict, No one else, unless you're going to be stupid enough and blame the Poles. Of course if you wish to compare Apples and Oranges we could say that Japanese attack in Manchuria in 1931, or Mussolini's invasion of Ethiopia in 1935 started the war, and maybe, just maybe, by extension you may prove your point, but again, ANY STANDARD AND RESPECTED HISTORY OF THE CONFLICT SAYS IT BEGAN 9/01.1939 AND THAT HITLER AND THE GERMANS STARTED IT. As for World War I it was GERMAN meddling that started the ball rolling EVEN if it was the actions of the Serb Gavrilo Princip who by murdering Count Franz Ferdinand and Princess Sophia in Sarajevo that may have been the catalyst. WE AMERICANS WERE FULLY PREPARED TO GO TO WAR WITH GERMANY IN 1889 WHEN THE GERMANS PUSHED THEIR WAY INTO SAMOA, AND ONLY A STORM THAT WRECKED THE GERMAN, U.S. AND BRITISH FLEETS PREVENTED A WAR THEN. Admiral Dewey 9 years later was prepared to fire on German Battleships that meddled in the Philippines following Dewey's crushing defeat of the Spanish Navy in the Battle of Manila Bay. And even 7 years later, President Roosevelt had put our military on a war footing over German designs on Morocco. THE LATTER A FULL 8 YEARS BEFORE SARAJEVO. And after the assassination of Ferdinand and Sophia Germany could have reined in Austria-Hungary. IT CHOSE NOT TO BUT EGGED THE AUSTRIANS ON. GERMAN PLOTS AND MEDDLING IF NOT AN ACTUAL FIGHT HELPED BRING ABOUT THE START OF WORLD WAR I. As said, prove otherwise.
**there are any to choose from...
I wonder Professor if when choosing which Angry Reader to choose from that display both anger and cogency of thought? As a voracious consumer of your articles and speaking appearances, I understand the difficulty of arguing logically against your observations proscriptions and predictions. You’re truly a national treasure on the level of Dr Charles Krauthammer in my opinion
Bahahaha, that's funny!!!!
Both Nicaragua and Venezuela are about to blow. My source in the region suggests USA get ready for addressing this, perhaps with military intervention being the only solution. Of course President Trump will be blamed for not doing something sooner.
The person who left the comment that stated Germany did not start WW1 or WW2, please tell us who did.
Oh, yeah? Well, that’s not what she read on Facebook.