Victor Davis Hanson
Almost daily, western news agencies quote “15,000 civilian deaths” caused by the Israel Defense Forces. They once at least used to qualify “according to Hamas authorities.”
Now they don’t even do that much, but employ “Palestinian authorities,” as a euphemism for Hamas liars.
How does Hamas know the roughly exact number of “civilian” causalities, but not the number of Hamas warriors dead? Do surveillance photos reveal vast new civilian cemeteries that could accommodate such a vast count? Or is Hamas burying its terrorist deaths separately?
Did Hamas gain credibility by falsely reporting an Israeli bombing hit on a hospital that killed “500 civilians”? By falsely bragging that there were no tunnel complexes under the hospital. By falsely reporting hostages were killed by Israeli air strikes rather than being passed off to terrorist splinter groups who dispatched them?
Hamas claims simultaneously that 1) it did not break the ceasefire; 2) but it boasted about and claimed credit for two terrorist brothers from Jerusalem who murdered four Israelis and injured six during the ceasefire by simply driving down a street, jumping out, and shooting civilians before they were gunned down by off-duty soldiers; 3) it bragged it had launched more rockets into Israeli civilian centers; and 4) during the ceasefire Hamas leaders have promised to renew the war and shortly to top the October 7 murdering spree.
Are we thus to assume this is a legitimate entity with which any nation would wish to conduct any sort of negotiations?
What did Kamala Harris, Middle East expert, mean when she warned Israel, “Too many innocent Palestinians have been killed. Frankly, the scale of civilian suffering and the images and videos coming from Gaza are devastating.” Did she remark on the “devastating” mutilations and decapitations of October 7? What does she think the U.S. military did in Mosul or Fallujah to root out ISIS and Saddamite terrorists other than use “devastating” methods?
One can see how in cynical fashion the beleaguered Biden triangulating administration once again outsources an unenviable task for the DEI Kamala Harris, on the expectation that her incompetence will further embarrass her, and thus win public opinion to whatever position is the exact opposite of her advocacy. As she weighs in to empathize with the pro-Hamas crowd, her nonsense only further discredits them.
What does Antony Blinken mean when he reportedly said to the Israeli government, “I don’t think you have the credit for that” in response to Israeli promises to spend necessary months to destroy Hamas? Did he mean, “If you put us in an embarrassing situation with our Arab-Muslim constituencies, we will cut off arms to you”?
But did Congress not pass a massive aid bill for Israel? And did not Blinken’s Party once impeach Donald Trump for delaying military aid to Ukraine to leverage the Ukrainian government to audit its corrupt government agencies that were buying influence into the Biden family, which in exchange had offered protection money by firing nosy prosecutors?
So, is Blinken predicating the sending of congressionally approved vital help to Israel on the basis of what he feels are domestic political considerations in an election year—such as, further Israeli attacks alienate Arab-Muslim voters, who promise in turn not to vote for Biden, so Blinken warns Israel they have limited “credit”?
Here is the bottom line. The Middle East will blow up if Hamas is not destroyed—even as Europeans, moderate Arabs, and the U.S. population all desire its end. But to see Hamas gone will be a media circus that will spark protests throughout the world and likely violence. Everyone knows that if police broke up such violent riots, deported law-breaking resident aliens, and charged citizens for their illegality, the violence would stop.
And everyone knows if Hamas is dismantled, Hezbollah will do nothing. Iran will do nothing, and the Arab nations will do nothing—other than be relieved.
So, everybody knows the cure for the Hamas evil and its supporters, and no one wishes to apply the short-term medicine.
How the Biden administration figured that Hamas’s survival is in the interest of the United States, or that allowing thousands to come from the terrorist nations of the Middle East into the U.S. is wise immigration policy, or sending embargoed money to Iran is necessary, make no sense other than either Biden’s team is utterly incompetent or feel Israel’s enemies are more important to us alive and active than Israel being stuck in perpetual danger.
Discussion (8)
Join the conversation. Logged in subscribers avoid the Captcha verification and get priority commenting approvals. No vulgarity, links, or code allowed.
I would appreciate clarification by what is meant by the “two-state-solution.” The Jewish people are clearly identified in the historical record as having had a self-governing and culturally separate polity (sometime totally independent kingdoms) with geographically identified landmarks. Palestine (according to Wikipedia) was a name applied to a province of the Roman Empire or a military district of various Muslim empires. In modern times it referred to a region administered by Great Britain after the dismemberment of the Ottoman Empire. Historically there had been a distinct country called Israel, but is it true that in the past Palestine was instead regarded as an area or a region? Since the offer to establish a country called Palestine was accepted by the Jewish people but rejected by some non-Jewish people, there have been a series of wars and bloodshed. Which brings me to my question – the current anti-Israel sentiment seems to exist in three politically separate and geographically distinct areas: Gaza; the West-bank; and southern Lebanon. This suggests a “four-state-solution” - that seems even less likely than a “two-state-solution.” My hope is that VDH might be able to provide clarification, and suggestions.
Respectfully, I don't understand why you think the US has been a hindrance rather than a help to Israel; tho this administration by Jacobins is questionable. Israel's biggest problem was giving up land for peace, twice imo. Thinking people would see they wanted peace and good. But when you are a vulnerable scapegoat, you can do no right. So now that 'peace' contract has been shattered by the so called palis, constantly. Any other country would be considered justified in taking back their land. But a constantly extorted Israel is afraid to take its land back for fear it will lose backing if a war takes place. Jews are rightfully haunted by the Holocaust and the terrible publicity beating from the left.
“Palestinian authorities,” as a euphemism for Hamas liars." I love this phrase from your article. Wish I could have seen it before my posts on news media trying to tell people that Hamas wasn't the proper group to listen to re: their casualties. Thank you for this article.
Victor, you did a very interesting podcast on Israel that aired Christmas Day of 2021- worth listening to again I believe. seems rather prophetic now, in a sad way.
Unfortunately, U.S. involvement in the peace process in Israel has resulted in decades of terrorist attacks and missile bombardments. It's time for the US to get out of the way and let Israel deploy an "Israel First" strategy. I believe Israel needs to create and clear a DMZ. They should expand this DMZ to any area where rockets are launched from (this would be the best deterrence from further rocket attacks). Once stability is reached and attacks have subsided they should announce a plan to resume peace talks after 100 years have passed without additional attacks.
"...make no sense other than either Biden’s team is utterly incompetent or feel Israel’s enemies are more important to us alive and active than Israel being stuck in perpetual danger". There is a third alternative: the "Biden" administration seeks the diminution, and eventual destruction, of the state of Israel and the Jewish people and will employ any means, method, venom, murderous horde, and barrage of ongoing calumnies to accomplish the desired outcome. In chaos there is opportunity, especially for the globally venal would be overlords who would see us all serve their wants with boots on our faces continually.
Can anyone cite anything from Hamas that hasn't proven demonstrably false? The still-dominant media's acceptance of Hamas as a legitimate news source is farcical. Shame, too, on these "journalists."